The Lanc Local team analyzed 67,003 local reviews and metrics to find the best pizza restaurants Talmage, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Pizza Restaurants
Near Talmage, PA
Nonna Rosa Traditional Italian Kitchen
4.7
(903 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Food was exceptional. There were so many good things to choose from. The mozzarella fritta and penne vodka was to die for! We had the peanut butter explosion cake which was so moist and so very delicious. Very beautiful on the inside and seating is very comfy. We visited on Mother's Day and they ha...
Akron
Rosario’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.7
(730 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Overall a 5. Been a long time since I've had pizza this good."...
Leola
DiMaria’s Pizza And Italian Kitchen
4.7
(722 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Always amazing food and fabulous service. Tonight's Eggplant Tower was almost too pretty to eat. The eggplant was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crispy crunch, and the basil, tomatoes, balsamic, and pesto kicked the Caprese up to a whole new level. Love the shrimp scampi and eve...
Ephrata
LUCA
4.6
(1,347 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is an awesome spot located on the outskirts of the city. Really wasn’t expecting to see how unique the building is. Everything we ordered was phenomenal! So delicious. The staff was very friendly and super accommodating! We were there on a Tuesday night and it was busy! Although it was busy ...
Lancaster
Pasquale’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
4.6
(1,347 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is an awesome spot located on the outskirts of the city. Really wasn’t expecting to see how unique the building is. Everything we ordered was phenomenal! So delicious. The staff was very friendly and super accommodating! We were there on a Tuesday night and it was busy! Although it was busy ...
Lancaster
The Fridge
4.6
(986 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First time coming here with a friend and I wasn’t disappointed! Neither of us waited that long for our food and it was delicious! Best pizza I’ve had in awhile. There was inside and outside seating & plenty of space for everyone. They had plenty of drink options, including non alcoholic. This p...
Lancaster
Brooklyn Pizza – Grill
4.6
(982 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The mother ship has called me home!!! I’m from NY and have been out here for 8 years and just found this place. The food speaks for itself. Best pizza around. The atmosphere is identical to a NY pizzeria. The service was amazing. I was using a cane because I had surgery and the kid at the registe...
Lancaster
CJEphrata Pizza
4.7
(481 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The Cuban sandwich was out of this world. Will definitely be back for that sandwich again. The bread was crispy and perfect. The empanadas were hot and fresh. Taste was great. Service was wonderful and had a smile. They were very nice and pleasant people."...
Ephrata
Little Nicki’s Pizza
4.7
(462 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I passed by Little Nicki’s for over 15 years and finally did stop in on a Monday night for dinner.
Their menu has an amazing amount of items that I could chose from.
I was amazed on the portion sizes and how reasonable their prices are.
Service was on the ball and my server was very informativ...
Ephrata
Pie In the Sky
4.7
(395 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I’ve gone here a few times with my mom and my kids. Today we enjoyed pizza and chicken tenders. My oldest does not usually like pizza , however she said today that this is the BEST pizza ever. I have to agree that the food here is so incredibly good! Everything we have ever had here has been deli...
Lancaster