The Lanc Local team analyzed 53,597 local reviews and metrics to find the best italian restaurants Talmage, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Italian Restaurants
Near Talmage, PA
Nonna Rosa Traditional Italian Kitchen
4.7
(903 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Food was exceptional. There were so many good things to choose from. The mozzarella fritta and penne vodka was to die for! We had the peanut butter explosion cake which was so moist and so very delicious. Very beautiful on the inside and seating is very comfy. We visited on Mother's Day and they ha...
Akron
Lititz Family Cupboard Restaurant & Buffet
4.6
(2,743 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First off this is a staple in the Brickerville area of Northern Lancaster County. Parking may be a little tight but there is parking in the back so don’t be discouraged. Once you enter it’s nice and warm and inviting. The staff is super nice and knows the menu inside and out. Not a bad seat in ...
Lititz
Brickerville House Restaurant
4.6
(2,739 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First off this is a staple in the Brickerville area of Northern Lancaster County. Parking may be a little tight but there is parking in the back so don’t be discouraged. Once you enter it’s nice and warm and inviting. The staff is super nice and knows the menu inside and out. Not a bad seat in ...
Lititz
Rosario’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.7
(730 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Overall a 5. Been a long time since I've had pizza this good."...
Leola
DiMaria’s Pizza And Italian Kitchen
4.7
(722 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Always amazing food and fabulous service. Tonight's Eggplant Tower was almost too pretty to eat. The eggplant was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crispy crunch, and the basil, tomatoes, balsamic, and pesto kicked the Caprese up to a whole new level. Love the shrimp scampi and eve...
Ephrata
LUCA
4.6
(1,591 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I’m not sure what else needs to be said about Luca, but it lives up to any hype. Went there for Mother’s Day and made small mix up in my reservation. They were very gracious and helped us with that.
The staff is just excellent. Friendly. Attentive. And I’d ever add, cool. The place is just...
Lancaster
Brooklyn Pizza – Grill
4.6
(982 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The mother ship has called me home!!! I’m from NY and have been out here for 8 years and just found this place. The food speaks for itself. Best pizza around. The atmosphere is identical to a NY pizzeria. The service was amazing. I was using a cane because I had surgery and the kid at the registe...
Lancaster
CJEphrata Pizza
4.7
(481 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The Cuban sandwich was out of this world. Will definitely be back for that sandwich again. The bread was crispy and perfect. The empanadas were hot and fresh. Taste was great. Service was wonderful and had a smile. They were very nice and pleasant people."...
Ephrata
Two Cousins Pizza Ristorante Italiano
4.6
(848 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've been here 2 times, and both were wonderful experiences. I come during lunch break for their lunch specials, and the food is wonderfully priced. Last time, I got their burger and fries lunch special (burger and fries, no drink included) for 8$ and was not expecting as many fries to be filling t...
Stevens
Gibraltar Restaurant
4.6
(720 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We easily made reservations online and we’re seated right away when arriving. The staff from the time we came in and left were absolutely amazing, super attentive and friendly. They were also very knowledgeable about the menu and answered any of the questions we had. The drinks selection was exte...
Lancaster