The Lanc Local team analyzed 66,968 local reviews and metrics to find the best sandwich shops Reamstown, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Sandwich Shops
Near Reamstown, PA
Gracie’s On West Main
4.7
(2,774 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We went for the grilled cheese, and we weren't disappointed. It was probably the best grilled cheese I've ever had. Delicious bacon, chicken, and of course the cheese melted to perfection on sourdough. A fabulous combination. My girl had the pulled pork grilled cheese, which of course she loved. An...
Leola
Lititz Family Cupboard Restaurant & Buffet
4.6
(2,743 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First off this is a staple in the Brickerville area of Northern Lancaster County. Parking may be a little tight but there is parking in the back so don’t be discouraged. Once you enter it’s nice and warm and inviting. The staff is super nice and knows the menu inside and out. Not a bad seat in ...
Lititz
Brickerville House Restaurant
4.6
(2,739 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First off this is a staple in the Brickerville area of Northern Lancaster County. Parking may be a little tight but there is parking in the back so don’t be discouraged. Once you enter it’s nice and warm and inviting. The staff is super nice and knows the menu inside and out. Not a bad seat in ...
Lititz
Two Cousins Pizza Ristorante Italiano
4.6
(848 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've been here 2 times, and both were wonderful experiences. I come during lunch break for their lunch specials, and the food is wonderfully priced. Last time, I got their burger and fries lunch special (burger and fries, no drink included) for 8$ and was not expecting as many fries to be filling t...
Stevens
Jersey Mike’s Subs
4.6
(261 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Saw the sign, parked and walked inside. I was greeted by a very nice person who knew what they were doing. I requested a specific meal and was asked a number of questions about how I wanted my sandwich. Their suggestions probably made the sandwich better and when I ate within the establishment, it ...
Ephrata
PJ’s Steak & Hoagie Shack
4.6
(228 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very good cheese steaks, prompt, courteous and friendly service.
Stopped by for take out cheese steaks (medium) with curly fries. The cheese steaks were quite good and an ample portion. The rolls were right, the meat juicy, perhaps a bit more cheese would have been good - but overall very good. Th...
New Holland
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
4.3
(369 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very nice place! We get smoothies there every morning and the manager is super nice!! We always have a good experience and she pays close detail to everything!! She knows my order and name as soon as I walk in!! That’s rare to find a manager that pays that close attention!!"...
Ephrata
Isaac’s Restaurant – Ephrata
4.3
(361 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Of course, the Pickels are good! I had the chicken brest on a pretzel roll with munster cheese! It's was delicious."...
Ephrata
The New Cloister Restaurant
4.3
(361 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Of course, the Pickels are good! I had the chicken brest on a pretzel roll with munster cheese! It's was delicious." - A G....
Ephrata
Jimmie’s Thing Hoagies, Heroes, Sandwiches, Subs and More
4.7
(22 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We are so glad they opened back up. There are no subs this good in the area. I had the Rittenhouse and it was beyond delicious. The kids loved their turkey subs, and my husband was impressed by just how much bacon was on the Kevin Bacon. We can’t wait to get it again soon!!"...
Leola