The Lanc Local team analyzed 53,597 local reviews and metrics to find the best italian restaurants Paradise, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Italian Restaurants
Near Paradise, PA
Rosario’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.7
(730 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Overall a 5. Been a long time since I've had pizza this good."...
Leola
Gibraltar Restaurant
4.6
(720 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We easily made reservations online and we’re seated right away when arriving. The staff from the time we came in and left were absolutely amazing, super attentive and friendly. They were also very knowledgeable about the menu and answered any of the questions we had. The drinks selection was exte...
Lancaster
Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant
4.5
(1,177 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Can’t recommend Palermo’s enough, their food and service is always great."...
New Holland
Osteria Avanti
4.7
(239 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We visited the Inn at Leola Village for one night on our drive home from our New England vacation and it was amazing! My husband and I both enjoyed everything we ordered at Osteria Avanti. We sat outside in their herb garden which was beautiful and they had live music the night we were there! Reser...
Leola
Two Cousins Pizza Paradise
4.5
(606 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Stopped after a day out at Dutch Wonderland. About 8pm Sunday night and we found this pizza restaurant. Very good Pizza, staff very welcoming. I had a pleasure to meet one of the owners Salvatore, was nice to exchange words in Italian with him.
We will try to stop again if the area."...
Paradise
Strasburg Pizza
4.5
(569 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A true little gem in the heart of Amish country! The plain slices were delicious!! The crust was crunchy with no flop and the sauce was the perfect balance of tang to sweet! Highly recommend!!"...
Strasburg
Vinny and ThozeGuyz Pizzeria
4.5
(460 Reviews)
Featured review:
"CarryOut/small dining area pizza joint.
We drove by and stopped on a whim, ...great decision. Friendly staff and excellent food.
'There's always room for pizza', especially when it's this good."...
Lancaster
Leola Pizza
4.6
(233 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Ive been to a LOT of pizza shops and wow does Leola pizza insert itself at the top. Just moved to Leola about a month ago and they already made themselves our go to. They are so incredibly kind and make sure to listen to how you would like your food. When I went someone was having their birthday pa...
Leola
Strasburg Pizza
4.5
(406 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Pizza was good. Service was great and the owner was nice." - Jerry...
Strasburg
Pizza City
4.5
(406 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We went there out of recommendation of my cousin from new jersey. It did not disappoint. Reminded me of my childhood pizza but it holds it's form better. I recommend the sma drive and eating here over any dutch wonderland food for sure."...
Strasburg