The Lanc Local team analyzed 16,651 local reviews and metrics to find the best wine stores New Providence, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Wine Stores
Near New Providence, PA
Passerine
4.7
(104 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Had a wonderful dinner here last night as an early Mother’s Day celebration. Very welcoming atmosphere, menu is focused (which is always a good sign everything will be masterfully prepared!) and included some unique items. Had the zucchini crepe cake as an appetizer that was delicious, with the c...
Lancaster
Nissley Vineyards Wine Shop & Tasting Room
4.8
(61 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great experience. The staff are super nice. The wines are great."...
Lancaster
Sam’s Pizza
4.3
(593 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We grabbed a few slices to go, and I was in and out fairly quickly. We tried the Buffalo chicken, Taco, and plain cheese. They were all great. The Taco meat had a great flavor. The toppings definitely were not skimpy."...
Quarryville
Waltz Vineyards Wine Shop
4.4
(54 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great wine shop! We visited this twice before and really enjoy the wine and wine samples. I got the Crow Woods Cabernet - it was very rich and had a unique taste to it. My husband really enjoyed the sweeter wines. Definitely recommend checking out this shop while in Kitchen Kettle Village."...
Gordonville
Sheetz
4.2
(262 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I went inside to order food for my kids I am on crutches due to recovery of hip surgery, I would like to give a shout out to the employee who was working at that time as he asked me why I was on crutches I explained, he then proceeded to ask me if I needed any assistance I told him I did he asked w...
Lancaster
Sheetz
3.8
(58 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Spicy chicken salad... Surprisingly good! The heat on the chicken is on point. I would recommend people to try it at least one time . My salad... Croutons, Cheese, Black Olives, Sweet peppers, Jalapenos and Oil/Vinegar dressing "...
Lancaster
Sheetz
3.7
(93 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Pleasant knowledgeable associates working. Plenty of prepared and made to order food options available. Well stocked clean convenience store. Plenty of gas pumps available at a decent price."...
Lancaster
Rutter’s
4
(338 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Good clean gas station. ⛽️ can't get rhe quality of food like a wawa or sheetz. But worth a stop!"...
Strasburg
Sheetz
3.1
(135 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is a beautiful Sheetz location. The parking lot is easy to pull into, and I’ve never had any issue finding a parking spot. The store is clean and very well upkept. It’s quick and easy using the made to order screen and the food is delicious. The self checkout process is the fastest and eas...
Lancaster