The Lanc Local team analyzed 4,472 local reviews and metrics to find the best shoe stores New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Shoe Stores
Near New Providence, PA
Good’s Store
4.6
(1,392 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great store! Just learned that my grandmother shopped there back in the day, my dad is a regular, and I will definitely be keeping the tradition." - Gardening w....
Quarryville
Leacock Shoe Store
4.6
(143 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I'm told by friends ive taken here they are very pleased with the selection and can find what they want at a good price, brought a young amish man here from Southern Lancaster County, so he traveled 28 miles one way to come here. They have a upstairs with toys and Amish clothing and baby clothes,...
Paradise
Red Wing – Lancaster, PA
4.8
(72 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Had to come in for work boots. My hubby’s company recommended Red Wing Shoes. Came in and worked with Cheyann—she was wonderful. Very informative, professional and beyond helpful. She made the buying process so easy. Great employee to go with a great product!" - Deb B....
Lancaster
Shoes n Gifts
4.9
(10 Reviews)
Featured review:
"They generally always have the sizes you need and a good variety of shoes and boots for children, men, and women. They have a nice selection of gift items, books, children's toys, stationery, etc. Their sales are always excellent. Also, the little boys are adorable who are little n have lemonade sa...
Drumore
Chico’s Off The Rack
4.3
(50 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very friendly, warm welcoming sales staff who are very helpful without being "pushy". Gorgeous selection of tops and slacks. Really easy to put together lots of adorable outfits. Great sales, too, with 40-60% off. Plus, a rack of final markdowns in the back by the fitting rooms. Great store
Target
4.2
(815 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is a great branch of Target which include CVS and Starbucks, can you imagine how all these goodies are packed together... I've visited with my parents, mom and dad but my sister wasn't with us, for part of the time she was with us on a video call"...
Lancaster
Walmart Supercenter
4.2
(815 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is a great branch of Target which include CVS and Starbucks, can you imagine how all these goodies are packed together... I've visited with my parents, mom and dad but my sister wasn't with us, for part of the time she was with us on a video call" - yuval f....
Lancaster
francesca’s
3.7
(46 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Oh my gosh, I can't believe I've never come here before. The sales person helping us was so, so nice and helpful, they have beautiful items, and great prices! I found my new favorite store!" - Yvonne D....
Lancaster
Timberland Outlet – Lancaster Pa
4.3
(244 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excelente lugar para comprar una de las más prestigiosas marcas en zapatos de aventura." - Luis A....
Lancaster
Merrell
4.4
(142 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Staff were very helpful and friendly. Merrell makes such great quality shoes. I continue to only buy my snow boots from them. Lots of other comfy shoes too." - Chelsea...
Lancaster