The Lanc Local team analyzed 6,959 local reviews and metrics to find the best jewelers New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Jewelers
Near New Providence, PA
Ream Jewelers Fine Jewelry
5
(547 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Ream Jewelers is the best in Lancaster. Recently, I needed to have one of my rings sized. It was a little complicated because it had sizing beads on it. They made sure that the fit was correct and that I was happy with the results. I recommend Reams as the premiere jewelers anywhere! Thank you...
Lancaster
KAY Outlet
4.6
(112 Reviews)
Featured review:
"VERY nice people, they weren’t pushy, and Nice. Chelsea was amazing to work with, and help us get (in all honesty) Great prices on real diamonds for a new ring!" - Cory L....
Lancaster
City Line Jeweler
4.6
(82 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have been going here for all my jewelry since I was 9 years old, and now my kids have pieces from here. Def family more than anything. Pete is your go to guy for all your custom made pieces." - Carlos R....
Lancaster
Laura Z Tai Fine Jewelry and Watches
5
(31 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Absolutely love the Laura Z Tai Fine Jewelry and Watch store! Laura and Alex both make the customer experience truly special and have tremendous knowledge. Bought several pieces from them and definitely looking forward to picking up my latest purchase; a new Baumé & Mercier watch. This is a new ex...
Lancaster
J.A. Sharp Custom Jeweler
5
(22 Reviews)
Featured review:
"JA Sharp fixed the broken chain on my necklace & now it's better than new! Very pleased with the service and care :)" - Allegra J....
Lancaster
The Jewelry Bar
4.2
(22 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A friendly knowledgeable helpful staff to guide you through the entire experience. A fun place to visit in purchase" - Dean S....
Intercourse
Timeless Piercing & Jewelers
5
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I HIGHLY recommend Charlie for any piercing. I have had a few piercings performed by them and I can’t wait for more. Not only are they extremely knowledgeable and professional, they care about you and your piercing goals. They always maintain a clean, organized, kind and welcoming safe environmen...
Lancaster
Forresters Eclectic Wares
5
(3 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Some of the best stuff that I have found available with great fast service and beautiful loving people." - William J....
Holtwood
United Jewelry
4
(2 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Mr. Bob is helpful, prompt, knowledgeable and just plain enjoyable to chat with. He keeps wanting to retire and I keep hoping he will not - been taking our watches for batteries and jewelry repairs to him for years now." - Margo...
Lancaster