The Lanc Local team analyzed 7,661 local reviews and metrics to find the best hardware stores New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Hardware Stores
Near New Providence, PA
Good’s Store
4.6
(1,392 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great store! Just learned that my grandmother shopped there back in the day, my dad is a regular, and I will definitely be keeping the tradition." - Gardening w....
Quarryville
Esh Hardware & Farm Supply
4.8
(161 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A well supplied hardware store near Intercourse owned and operated by Amish. Friendly, helpful employees. Good folks to deal with." - Lawrence G....
Ronks
Green Tree Hardware
4.7
(164 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Best Amish hardware store in the area hands-down. simply incredible prices and selection, cash or check only. I buy all of my power tools for work from here and stop by at least once a week for supplies." - Rodney H....
Quarryville
W. L. Zimmerman & Sons
4.7
(265 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Nice store, very friendly staff here. They had in stock what I came there for and the employee was very helpful pointing out where to find what I needed." - James W....
Ronks
Zimmerman’s Ace Hardware
4.7
(265 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Nice store, very friendly staff here. They had in stock what I came there for and the employee was very helpful pointing out where to find what I needed."...
Ronks
E M Herr Farm & Home Center
4.5
(438 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The sales clerk was very helpfully when inquired about filling my propane tank. The gentleman who filled my propane tank was helpful, when it was raining. Thanks again EM Herr. Will be back soon"...
Willow Street
Esh Hardware & Farm Supply
4.5
(438 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The sales clerk was very helpfully when inquired about filling my propane tank. The gentleman who filled my propane tank was helpful, when it was raining. Thanks again EM Herr. Will be back soon" - Herbert W....
Willow Street
Holtwood Supply
4.6
(183 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This spot is like the old SS store but your Amish buddy owns it. Great place for propane they just went up to 2 but still cheapest in 100 miles you can find anything from fence, gates, wire your place. Get a cold drink and a snack. Fair honest people with great prices just about anything you need" ...
Holtwood
A & J Power Equipment
4.7
(120 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This place is awesome! They have lots & lots of things from almost any construction power tool to hand tools to many, many fasteners to gardening & outdoor tools. Great all around local hardware store. They also have a rental department that has lots of construction power tools, nail guns, Scaff...
Bird in Hand
Harbor Freight Tools
4.4
(909 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Needed a little help tonight while shopping and they were very helpful and nice to deal with. Great experience. Also, I noticed they changed the layout of the cash registers and lines to pay and leave. 2 huge thumbs up for that." - Matt A....
Lancaster