The Lanc Local team analyzed 98 local reviews and metrics to find the best guest houses New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Guest houses
Near New Providence, PA
Bird-in-Hand Village Inn & Suites
4.7
(182 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We have stayed at this inn many times and always have a wonderful experience. The grounds are beautifully maintained, and the rooms are comfortable with lovely decor. We always look forward to our next visit."...
Bird in Hand
Osceola Mill House Bed & Breakfast
4.8
(98 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This Old Colonial Pre-Revolutionary War Home is charming, cozy, warm, and situated in the country where you can hear the sound of the clip-clopping of the horses hooves as they pulled their owners buggy. Each guest room is color named and the Amish Bed quilt is of that color as are the accessories....
Gordonville
Flory’s Cottages & Camping
4.6
(137 Reviews)
Featured review:
"One of the most welcoming campgrounds we have ever stayed at. We were guided to our campsite and the owner stayed with us until we were backed in and connected to ensure we were happy. We were traveling with another coupled and they ensured our sites were side by side and in the area of the campgro...
Ronks
Willow Breeze Guest Home
4.9
(14 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We have stayed here a few times and it is our favorite place to stay when coming to Lancaster. We have always stayed in the Cow Room, which lovely and comfortable, though my wife is no longer able to do stairs, so from now on we will have to stay in the Sunrise Suite, which is also terrific. The ho...
Lancaster
Beacon Hollow Farm Bed & Breakfast
4.6
(25 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This was an incredible place to stay! It was so beautiful and peaceful! The animals were an added joy. We enjoyed watching the cows go in to be milked. We even got to pet them.They also have turkeys and chickens, beautiful dogs too! The breakfast was the best of our trip! Homemade blueberry, granol...
Gordonville
Amish Guest House & Cottage
4.6
(21 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Daniel’ Amish house is truly an amazing place to stay! The house comes complete with everything you could want and more! The hot tub and backyard with fire pit and surrounding comfy Adirondack chairs are awesome. It was so clean it lived up to my OCD standards! The furniture inside is all decorat...
Intercourse
Dutch Homestead Vacation Home
4.9
(11 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Wonderful hosts, perfect place to stay to recharge and experience the best of Amish Country. Guesthouse was immaculate and could not have been more thoughtfully prepared for our stay. Cannot say enough about Miriam, Reuben and their family. One of the best experiences of my life."...
Ronks
Esh Country Guesthouse
5
(9 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Wonderful! Although I didn't get to meet Mr. Esh during my stay I wanted to write a review to say Thank You for the wonderful experience. Another lady in our organization made the reservation for our group while we were attending the Make A Wish Convoy. The home was wonderful and we thoroughly enjo...
Gordonville
Mussers’ Historic Country Suites
5
(9 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We stayed at this lovely, cozy, historic bed and breakfast for Memorial Day weekend. We loved the charm of the room. My whole family (4kids, hubby and my mom!) fit very comfortably and we had room for more. My kids loved the room with the bunk bed! The place was immaculate. Barb was so friendly and...
New Providence
Lancaster School House
5
(5 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Such a sweet place and incredibly close to our wedding venue! Love working with the people too and such a great sense of style. The jacuzzi is a great find! Super relaxing spot to stay at after a stressful day thank you again Tyler for having us :)"...
Willow Street