The Lanc Local team analyzed 1,222 local reviews and metrics to find the best caterers New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Caterers
Near New Providence, PA
Chick-fil-A
4.7
(4,400 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We came in around 8 PM and ordered a family meal which came out promptly with good service, though my club was missing a few toppings. I took it up, asking for lettuce, not realizing it was missing the other toppings to which I took it up again and told them I definitely didn’t eat it off the top...
Lancaster
Speckled Hen Coffee
4.7
(1,615 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A delightful experience! I ordered the Specked Hen Latte (maple syrup and cinnamon). It was honestly one of the best lattes I've ever had, and so pretty! Two of us split a Lancaster omelette and a Specked Hen omelette. Both were delicious! Breakfast potatoes were cooked perfectly and nicely seasone...
Strasburg
Frisco’s Chicken Lancaster City
4.7
(573 Reviews)
Featured review:
"THIS IS WHERE YOU NEED TO GO FOR LUNCH. Seriously, it was delicious. We stopped here after the science center and we were so glad we did. The chicken was amazing. So much flavor. The yucca fries were great and the little guy loved the rice and beans. We will definitely come back if we are in the ar...
Lancaster
Hess Barbecue Catering
4.9
(106 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We chose Hess to cater our wedding because OMG this food is AMAZING. Not only is the food incredible, they also have a wide variety of options and are super willing to work with anything you may want. Their prices are super reasonable and they have several different packages you can pick from. They...
Willow Street
Prince Street Cafe, Lancaster
4.5
(1,238 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I had heard so much about Prince Street Cafe and am so happy I finally tried it out!! From the fun coffee flavors (and also absolutely delicious) to the surplus of meal options for me (as a gluten free gal), I was so happy with my meal! It is in a convenient location, close to so many other fun thi...
Lancaster
New Holland Coffee Co.
4.6
(201 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We rented the Lancaster location for a bridal shower and it was perfect! Hannah was an amazing staff hostess and the atmosphere was stunning. It was so easy to plan our specific needs with Mikayla- just so professional and perfect. Everyone raved about the event, venue and coffee. Highly recommend...
Lancaster
The Greenfield Restaurant & Bar
4.3
(1,623 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Dined for dinner and Sunday brunch. Can’t speak more highly of this establishment. Impeccable plate presentation, food is top notch, service is excellent. Highly recommend for any meal, perfect to bring friends or family from out of town because they will be very pleased with their experience. Li...
Lancaster
Jersey Mike’s Subs
4.4
(155 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Recently discovered this place; best sandwiches around!"...
Lancaster
Jimmy John’s
5
(12 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Ran through to try the subs. Quick service, store was clean, sub looked great, and tasted even better. Will definitely be back."...
Lancaster
Upohar World Kitchen
5
(49 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Josiah and his team did an amazing job catering our wedding! they brought the food truck out to the venue and everyone was really impressed with the food. Service was great and went very smoothly, and every interaction we had with them was very professional and organized." - Linsey J....
Lancaster