The Lanc Local team analyzed 65,775 local reviews and metrics to find the best burger restaurants New Providence, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Burger Restaurants
Near New Providence, PA
Cabalar
4.8
(592 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Came here looking for Lancaster’s BEST Burger, and Cabalar has definitely thrown his hat in the ring. We had a Kids Burger and a House Special. Pleasantly surprised by the fries we upgraded to - fresh cut and crispy! They butcher their meat on-site and the result is a fresh and flavorful patty th...
Lancaster
Lancaster Brewing Company Taproom & Grill
4.4
(1,372 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This was a recommendation by a local for dinner.
Our waitress, Sydney was superb and attentive to all our needs.,She helped with sample beer drinks so we could get it right. The food was excellent and now I know I love a milk stout!"...
Lancaster
DJ’s Taste of the 50’s
4.4
(1,367 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Wow what a great place! No only were the burgers juicy and delicious the fries were hot and fresh and the onion rings were the best every time we took a bite the onion ring stayed together you didn't pull a huge chunk of the onion out! They have a nice selection of burgers and other sandwiches we w...
Lancaster
Wayback Burgers
4.1
(569 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I haven’t been here in YEARS but since moving back to PA, I HAD to come back and see if the food is just how I remember. IT WAS !! super delicious. I ordered a cheesy burger and after checking out had asked if I could pay to add bacon on it as well. I was told of course… no worries” and it wa...
Millersville
Friendly’s
4.1
(1,345 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Lisa R was very attentive and understanding. We really didn’t know what we wanted to eat, we just knew we wanted ice cream. I got the Captain’s platter with a butter crunch junior fribble. My food was fresh and hot and my ice cream was delicious. The banana split sundae was filling for my grand...
Lancaster
Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews
4.1
(2,980 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The burgers were absolutely amazing, as a vegetarian they had such great options. The impossible burger can be swapped for any of their traditional burgers which I loved. We got the onion ring tower, Oreo milkshakes and three burgers. We went in around lunch time and only had a 10 minute wait for o...
Lancaster
McDonald’s
3.7
(1,398 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The best Mcdonald’s in Lancaster! One of the managers’ that works there is truly a kind and sweet man! He always goes above and beyond with simple things like asking how my food is or offering me napkins. This does not happen just with one visit but multiple visits, he is just always so sweet! ...
Lancaster
McDonald’s
3.6
(1,412 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I was in a rush when I entered this Mc.donalds, no line food I ordered was hot n ready n tasty!!! no complaints"...
Lancaster
McDonald’s
3.6
(1,822 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This is a quality McDonalds. When I went, they still had the Hot n Spicy McChickens and they were happy to swap the mayo for Mac Sauce. Some dipwad cut me off on my way out, but that's not McDonalds fault, it's the fault of the dipwad in that white Subaru Legacy. Keep an eye out for them."...
Lancaster
McDonald’s
3.5
(1,839 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Not really sure of about all of negative review. I visit this McDonald's location frequently, and I must say it's the best one in Lancaster! I think it gets a bad rep because it's not located in the best part of town BUT I have never had an issue here and I have been frequenting this location for s...
Lancaster