The Lanc Local team analyzed 1,718 local reviews and metrics to find the best building supplies stores New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Building Supplies Stores
Near New Providence, PA
G R Mitchell Inc.
4.6
(139 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I am a big fan of hardware stores and farm stores. GR Mitchell did not disappoint. Lots of selection. Easy to locate. Easy in and out. Nice-sized parking lot. Friendly staff. Found exactly what I needed. I always feel good purchasing from a True Value. They have a good reputation." - Elizabeth H....
Willow Street
Bird In Hand Farm Supply
4.7
(83 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Neat place. Lit with gas lamps and the ventilation and ceiling fans are run on what looks like compressed air." - John P....
Bird in Hand
Wagler Steel
4.8
(38 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A great family run business that offers several metal roof and siding options in a wide variety of types and colors. Also has all the accessories from ridge caps, facia, rake, and all the trim pieces you'll need. Super knowledgeable and friendly staff that can help you figure out what you need for ...
Paradise
Strasburg Masonry Supply
4.6
(45 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Top quality products, small town feel & great pricing" - Covered B....
Strasburg
Solanco Building Supply
4.9
(21 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This place has a lot of building materials at great prices. Their customer service is great. Very helpful folks." - Jonathan H....
Quarryville
Premiere Building Products
4.9
(17 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great products..." - John P....
Gordonville
Lansing Building Products
4.4
(23 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Nice show room. Extremely helpful and friendly sales staff. You won't find a better place to buy windows, doors, etc. Can't say enough about the sales staff!" - Brenda M....
Lancaster
Builders FirstSource
4.2
(11 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Got my new front door from Paradise, great quality and fits well." - Nick M....
Paradise
Walter & Jackson Inc
3.7
(16 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I can't say enough about the professional assistance I had in selecting my quartz counter top. I chose my cabinets, then flooring, and then the Quartz. Probably not the usual order. Arlan helped with the perfect selection. I love my new kitchen, and the counter top is the stand out in the room....
Quarryville
Alside
4.8
(4 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have purchased products for my clients from Alside for over 10 years. They are great for what they are: moderately priced products, for well maintained and improved homes. These products are ideally suited for Lancaster homes in the 150,000-400,000 range. They have various levels of quality and f...
Lancaster