The Lanc Local team analyzed 19,817 local reviews and metrics to find the best bakeries New Providence, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Bakeries
Near New Providence, PA
Bird in Hand Bakeshop
4.8
(1,542 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This Bakeshop is the best! All of the baked goods are freshly made. You get to taste and try Amish made baked goods. There are lots of souvenir type things for sale. The best thing is the baked goods. You must try the whoopie pies! You can also get drinks so can enjoy a snack there or take it home ...
Bird in Hand
Immergut Hand-Rolled Soft Pretzels
4.8
(0 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Visited two weeks ago and can’t stop thinking about these pretzels. So good!" - M. van Oers...
Intercourse
Lancaster Pie & Coffee
5
(136 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This pie changed my life. I bought a mini berry pie at the market and it took me a couple days to cut into it as it was just so beautifully crafted. The two chicks behind the counter said they'd made them themselves with help from the owner's fabulous dough, and they were incredibly nice and unnece...
Lancaster
Stoltzfus Meats
4.7
(831 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The Stltzfus store is a store like no other that I have been in. They have a deli style restaurant inside with a very nice menu.
The meat case has the most amazing steaks, chicken and other fresh meat. My Wife and I always take a cooler with us when shopping at this store."...
Intercourse
Bistro Barberet & Bakery
4.7
(830 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We enjoyed a wonderful dinner. Mike, who was our bartender & server, explained the specials and answered our questions about the menu. We decided to enjoy oysters & beef tartare as appetizers. Our dinners included the chicken (phenomenal), the burger (outstanding) and a salad. The cocktails were su...
Lancaster
Edd’s & Flo’s Artisan Bakery Cafe
4.8
(442 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Extremely nice individuals working there! Delicious, fresh made, cinnamon rolls. And they now have them with apples on Thursdays. Might want to call ahead and order. They are AMAZING!!" - crystal l....
Lancaster
Mr Sticky’s Homemade Sticky Buns
4.8
(442 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Extremely nice individuals working there! Delicious, fresh made, cinnamon rolls. And they now have them with apples on Thursdays. Might want to call ahead and order. They are AMAZING!!"...
Lancaster
Torres Family Bakery LLC
4.6
(649 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great local bakery! The shop is small, but the food is grand . The bakery items are delicious, and the empanadas are great. They also have custom cakes to order as well, and sandwiches. There's a lot to offer in this little cute shop.
We got some pastries, and they are delicious and fresh. Defi...
Lancaster
Hammond’s Old-Fashioned Hand Made Pretzels
4.9
(242 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Snack central! Load up to munch on later, yum. Such a cute shop with fresh drips for your wardrobe, like T's and caps,"...
Lancaster
Auntie Anne’s
4.9
(242 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Snack central! Load up to munch on later, yum. Such a cute shop with fresh drips for your wardrobe, like T's and caps," - Amy '....
Lancaster