The Lanc Local team analyzed 5,456 local reviews and metrics to find the best tire shops New Holland, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Tire Shops
Near New Holland, PA
Raber’s Tire
4.7
(545 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Awsome ppl have been here to buy tires and to just swap out my aftermarket wheels out for my factory wheels and the prices are unbeatable honestly! thanks everyone at Raber tire for your services!" - Anthony M....
Ephrata
Tire Consultants Inc
4.8
(202 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Recommended by locals, walk in service. They had my tire size in stock, standard brands for my size. Took them all of 15 minutes to install. Great team. Behaved dog was welcome! Great way to support local business!" - Bchlvr66...
Ephrata
Pro Tire Service
4.9
(95 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A good trusted company the stuff is done right they really care about their work !! In my experience thus far .." - Amos M....
Kinzers
Martin’s Tire Services
4.8
(115 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have taken my vehicles to this shop for 30+ years and have seen a change of ownership from one generation to the next. I have stayed with Martin's Tire because of their fair prices, their kind owners/employees, and their expertise work. There is a comfortable waiting room with free coffee and wat...
Lititz
JR’s Collision
4.7
(122 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My car was in an accident and had front bumper and the back damaged and they got my car done in less than a week and it looks even better than when I bought it. Best shop I’ve been to!!" - Kennedy F....
Leola
Paul’s Auto Body
4.8
(36 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I recently had to use Paul's auto body shop for a fender bender incident along with a hit & run that all occurred in less than a week of one another. I was given an estimate by the insurance adjuster. It did not include the damage from the hit n run but Paul's auto body did an amazing job.fixing e...
Ephrata
Pep Boys – Lincoln Highway
4
(591 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excellent, kind staff. Quiet waiting room with a desk area, a coffee/tea station, a TV, and a restroom.
Appointments are suggested for service, I was told, so they can best plan staff hours.
Great service at a great price.
We had basic maintenance done - oil change, tire rotation - and paid abou...
Lancaster
Weaver’s Tire Services
4.9
(29 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Topnotch service! I had a tire pick up a screw on the turnpike and was unloading near weavers tire shop which is over 1000 miles from home and boy was i ever glad i found them, he got me fixed up in no time flat for very reasonable." - Lewis...
Ephrata
Paradise Truck Tire Specialists, Inc
4.4
(43 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Interesting place, to be sure!" - Larry G....
Paradise
Costco Tire Center
4.1
(31 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excellent customer service with Val at the front desk and John for tire selection, installation, and rotation. Our vehicles need gas every 1.5 to 2 weeks which we also get at Costco, so we use the self-serve machines to the left of the tire center to check and inflate our tires every time we fill o...
Lancaster