The Lanc Local team analyzed 12,559 local reviews and metrics to find the best pet stores Neffsville, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Pet Stores
Near Neffsville, PA
The Dog Fence Guy!®️
5
(468 Reviews)
Featured review:
"What a game changer!!
We were definitely skeptical at first, our oldest dog has always had a fenced in yard and our youngest, well… he’s like the second child. A little goofy, a little naughty. Both of our dogs adjusted so well! We couldn’t believe it.
Joe is so nice and very responsive. 10...
Lancaster
That Fish Place – That Pet Place
4.6
(8,255 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A huge store, with dogs, cats, reptiles, fish and other species-dedicated sections. They don’t carry high end animal related products but have a good selection and the store is spacious and organized. There is actually a cat rescue working from inside the store, allowing you to meet the cats and ...
Lancaster
Pet Supplies Plus Willow Street
4.8
(105 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Stopped in quickly to see what supplies they carry. They have a good selection of food, toys, enclosures, etc. for all kinds of pets, not just dogs and cats. Prices seem comparable to other local stores that sell pet supplies, so it might be worth stopping in now and then just to check it out, espe...
Willow Street
Tractor Supply Co.
4.5
(200 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A clean and neat store. The employees are upbeat, friendly, and pleasant to communicate with. They seem like they are having fun doing there job. One young lady in particular (Tina) always has a smile on her face which in turn always makes me feel better.
Thank you Tractor Supply.
You have a good...
Ronks
Farm Equipment
4.5
(200 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A clean and neat store. The employees are upbeat, friendly, and pleasant to communicate with. They seem like they are having fun doing there job. One young lady in particular (Tina) always has a smile on her face which in turn always makes me feel better.
Thank you Tractor Supply.
You have a g...
Ronks
Indulge Lititz (within Artisan Mill)
4.8
(24 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Artisan Mills is, for sure, one of my favorite places in Lititz! There are so many beautiful ,handmade items that you need for your house! I also love supporting our locals! " - Jennifer R....
Lititz
Pet Supplies Plus Lititz
4.6
(117 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We always stop here for the Hill’s brand of dry food for our senior cat, everyone is so nice when we shop here. Tonight we were surprised that we were chosen for a free bag of cat treats, toys, and food from their Cinco De Meow event. Our babies love their new toys & it was so nice of them to do ...
Lititz
Keystone Pet Place Lancaster
4.7
(61 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We absolutely LOVE Keystone Pet Place. My family and I recently moved to Lancaster County and we were in search of a small local pet business to support. We are so excited that we discovered Keystone Pet Place!!! First and foremost the staff and service are top notch. Everyone is so kind and person...
Lancaster
Pet Supplies Plus Ephrata
4.3
(114 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Best and cleanest self-serve dog wash in the area. I always get the Dirty Dog Card to save money." - klbrackin...
Ephrata
Wild Birds Unlimited
4.5
(65 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Staff was very knowledgeable and friendly. Yes it’s a bit pricey but they offer top quality items along with helpful guidance and great customer service! Needed a new way to feed the birds after installing a composite deck. Found everything we were looking for." - Liz J....
Lancaster