The Lanc Local team analyzed 2,108 local reviews and metrics to find the best sporting goods stores Mount Joy, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Sporting Goods Stores
Near Mount Joy, PA
Play It Again Sports
4.6
(470 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great place to get new and used gear or get rid of unwanted gear to buy more or size up. Always friendly and willing to help. I just love coming in here and can walk around looking for hours in the hockey, baseball and disc golfing items. I drive about 40 minutes to come to this place before drivin...
Lancaster
Kinsey’s Outdoors
4.5
(709 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I was able to purchase a beautiful used rifle from this establishment and what I expected to be a massive price tag was actually very affordable. Additionally, the staff that I worked with was very friendly and even took the time to tell me about it's history and making. Highly recommend stopping i...
Mount Joy
Christian’s Fitness Factory
4.6
(44 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We own a small gym. We're always looking to upgrade our equipment offerings, but have a limited budget. We were able to buy several great pieces for an awesome price. The owner is friendly, knowledgeable, and truly loves the industry. We'll definitely be back soon!" - Team C....
Lancaster
Target
3.7
(5,246 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've actually changed my rating from 2 years ago from one store to five stars. This store has really come a long way and it's much cleaner and more organized. The riff Raff customers that they get is not their problem and there's two bad there's not parents anymore for these wild kids who are likel...
Lancaster
Walmart
3.7
(5,246 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've actually changed my rating from 2 years ago from one store to five stars. This store has really come a long way and it's much cleaner and more organized. The riff Raff customers that they get is not their problem and there's two bad there's not parents anymore for these wild kids who are likel...
Lancaster
Pro Image Sports
3.2
(5 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This store is awesome, great selection, great prices, great shopkeepers. I was out of town, they made me a special order for a Dawkins jersey in a specific color that wasn’t even in stock, it was on my doorstep the very next week. I’ll definitely be purchasing through then in the future." - Fra...
Lancaster
October Mountain Products
3
(2 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I bought an OMP recurve bow from a dealer over a year ago. Recently I noticed the limbs were twisting. I contacted them and with very little information I had a new set of limbs, free of charge! Thank you!" - Jeff W....
Mount Joy