The Lanc Local team analyzed 4,589 local reviews and metrics to find the best cake shops Mount Joy, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Cake Shops
Near Mount Joy, PA
Taylor Chip Cookies
4.5
(1,494 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I bought a dozen for a friends birthday. It stated 2-5 days for delivery. It end up being 7 days. I was a bit disappointed. I was also really nervous about how they were going to be packaged. Since the were being delivered in the heat of Texas. But ...my mind was set at ease when they were delivere...
Lancaster
Great American Cookies
4.5
(1,494 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I bought a dozen for a friends birthday. It stated 2-5 days for delivery. It end up being 7 days. I was a bit disappointed. I was also really nervous about how they were going to be packaged. Since the were being delivered in the heat of Texas. But ...my mind was set at ease when they were delivere...
Lancaster
Made With Love Not Gluten Bakery
4.8
(183 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This bakery offers coconut milk for coffee, which is great. They also have GF pizza crusts, macaroni, and other non sweet items in a freezer for purchase."...
Mount Joy
Rise Bake Shoppe and Coffee Bar
4.8
(178 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This place is amazing! They are my GO TO bakery when ordering custom cakes! Their cakes are delicious, ordering the cakes is SUPER simple. I had ONE mishap where the computer system didn’t take my order, not sure what happened there however technology issues happen all the time HOWEVER! Their bak...
Mount Joy
Made With Love Not Gluten Bakery
4.8
(178 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This place is amazing! They are my GO TO bakery when ordering custom cakes! Their cakes are delicious, ordering the cakes is SUPER simple. I had ONE mishap where the computer system didn’t take my order, not sure what happened there however technology issues happen all the time HOWEVER! Their bak...
Mount Joy
Lancaster Cupcake
4.6
(281 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We chose to serve cupcakes from Lancaster Cupcake at our wedding, and they were a huge hit! Our guests loved the different flavors and we got many compliments on the taste of the cupcakes. We also got a small cutting cake, which was equally delicious and absolutely beautiful!
We did the pick-up ...
Lancaster
Good Life Ice Cream & Treats
4.4
(144 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We had our son’s birthday party at the science factory and at their recommendation, we went here afterwards for ice cream cake. The cake was delicious and the staff was great. They accommodated our large group and were very pleasant with his. Highly recommend!"...
Lancaster
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe
4.4
(144 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We had our son’s birthday party at the science factory and at their recommendation, we went here afterwards for ice cream cake. The cake was delicious and the staff was great. They accommodated our large group and were very pleasant with his. Highly recommend!" - Joel L....
Lancaster