The Lanc Local team analyzed 51,300 local reviews and metrics to find the best butcher shops Morgantown, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Butcher Shops
Near Morgantown, PA
Shady Maple Farm Market
4.7
(5,342 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This market has it all! Everything is such good quality, too. We spent hours in here, and my group spent almost $600 in total. We wanted it all. I recommend you come in here after you eat not before so you don't overbuy like we did. Can't wait to be back."...
East Earl
Martin’s Custom Butchering
4.9
(17 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Happy with the product and price, reasonably fast turnaround time.
Took a deer there, the summer sausage is awesome (wish I had gotten more than I did), the snack sticks (especially the spicy ones) are great as well. Wish I knew beforehand about how much venison I would have so I could plan accordi...
New Holland
J Mark Martin Butchering
4.9
(17 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Happy with the product and price, reasonably fast turnaround time.
Took a deer there, the summer sausage is awesome (wish I had gotten more than I did), the snack sticks (especially the spicy ones) are great as well. Wish I knew beforehand about how much venison I would have so I could plan accord...
New Holland
Hostetter Custom Butcher Shop
5
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I use Mr. Hostetter to order meat from on a regular basis. My husband takes all of his deer to him also. We have used Mr. Hostetter for meat for events as well as smoked turkey for Thanksgiving. I can't say enough about this shop. The family is so very kind and will get what you need by the time yo...
Mohnton
Balthaser Meat Market Inc
5
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I use Mr. Hostetter to order meat from on a regular basis. My husband takes all of his deer to him also. We have used Mr. Hostetter for meat for events as well as smoked turkey for Thanksgiving. I can't say enough about this shop. The family is so very kind and will get what you need by the time y...
Mohnton
Zimmerman’s Custom Butchering
4
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great experience. Fair prices and timely."...
New Holland
J Mark Martin Butchering
4
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great experience. Fair prices and timely." - John A....
New Holland