The Lanc Local team analyzed 5,456 local reviews and metrics to find the best tire shops Millersville, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Tire Shops
Near Millersville, PA
LTG Tires
4.8
(284 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I always take my car here. It’s a trek to get here, but I trust these guys with my car and the mechanics do a lot of work with aftermarket rims. I can trust them to not scratch my rims when I come here for new tires. Great place and great mechanics" - R...
Lancaster
Mavis Discount Tire
4.7
(577 Reviews)
Featured review:
"These guys were outstanding. Very knowledgeable. They were also patient enough with me to answer all my questions. They even had my car fixed before I expected." - Jacqueline H....
Lancaster
Transformed Auto Body LLC
4.9
(126 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I would highly recommend Brendan. He was very thorough in his review of the car when I brought it in. I had taken it to another shop to get an estimate and took it to Brendan for a second opinion. His knowledge and the time he took in looking the car over instilled confidence and I knew immediately...
Manheim
Jack Williams Tire & Auto Service Centers – Oregon Pike
4.6
(577 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This was absolutely the best experience ever. I mean no one wants to deal with a flat/ damaged tire on a busy day but if you have to this is the place to go. My son had a flat tire, which we were pretty sure was damaged beyond repair. I was able to make the appointment online, and we arrived about ...
Lancaster
Monro Auto Service and Tire Centers
4.6
(487 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I was in need of a last minute check up due to some travelling. Jerry was so friendly and was able to fit me right in and John serviced my car. He answered every one of my questions with ease and they even checked my tire pressure due to my light being on, explaining what services I may need in the...
Lancaster
NTB-National Tire & Battery
4.3
(422 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I brought my 2015 Nissan Altima in to have the tire patched due to running over a nail. The guys were all super polite and knowledgeable. They removed the nail and patched the tire quickly and efficiently! I am highly satisfied and will definitely be coming back in the future!" - Nia F....
Lancaster
McCarthy Tire Service
4.6
(76 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Those dudes are fun and they love what they do. Got a diagnosis of what was wrong. Turned out to be more than I expected. They told me what was wrong. Got!!! to spend some cash. I will gladly spend it with them. As Arnold said in terminator I'll be back." - Stephen T....
Lancaster
Pep Boys – Lincoln Highway
4
(591 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excellent, kind staff. Quiet waiting room with a desk area, a coffee/tea station, a TV, and a restroom.
Appointments are suggested for service, I was told, so they can best plan staff hours.
Great service at a great price.
We had basic maintenance done - oil change, tire rotation - and paid abou...
Lancaster
Myers Auto Body & Service Center
4.8
(33 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I called to have my review mirror replaced. The same day I got an estimate, I had service scheduled for 3 days later. It was done within 6 hours. The receptionist and auto body employee were very informative. The price they quoted me was reasonable but the actual price was about $60 cheaper. This i...
Manheim
Columbia Tire Outlet & Garage
3.9
(151 Reviews)
Featured review:
"These guys took great care of my truck. It needs inspection. They even went as far as crawling under the truck and hitting it with a greese gun. Didn't ask for it. Love a place that goes above and beyond . That's the kind of garage I need. I don't always know what's wrong. They looked not just di...
Columbia