The Lanc Local team analyzed 34,630 local reviews and metrics to find the best ice cream shops Maytown, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Ice Cream Shops
Near Maytown, PA
Forry’s Country Store
4.8
(568 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Forry's is my happy place!!! The staff is so nice and so are the customers.There are so many goodies in this little store.My favorites are the fresh made subs and different cheeses. Really great prices.Thank you for always making it a great experience every time I visit."...
Lancaster
The Country Store
4.8
(568 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Forry's is my happy place!!! The staff is so nice and so are the customers.There are so many goodies in this little store.My favorites are the fresh made subs and different cheeses. Really great prices.Thank you for always making it a great experience every time I visit." - Elena H....
Lancaster
Mulberry Thrill Outdoor Cafe
4.9
(125 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Very cute ice cream shop! There are a decent amount of flavors and things to get here. I definitely recommend it for a treat. It also has a few cute chairs and seating outside. It can get a little busy, but it's worth the wait!"...
Marietta
Bainbridge Inn
4.7
(394 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Food was delicious. Birch beer I asked my siblings to describe their food in 2 words: "Upside down" "Tastes great" "Yeah itdoes" "Quite decent" "Very chiplike" "Not bad" Large variety of options. I got a burger with a giant onion ring They chips taste original. And Donald trump was serving us sal...
Bainbridge
GiGi’s Ice Cream Bar
4.7
(393 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Food was delicious. Birch beer I asked my siblings to describe their food in 2 words: "Upside down" "Tastes great" "Yeah itdoes" "Quite decent" "Very chiplike" "Not bad" Large variety of options. I got a burger with a giant onion ring They chips taste original. And Donald trump was serving...
Bainbridge
Mountville Family Restaurant
4.6
(591 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Located near a great hotel this little restaurant really rocks. They feature outdoor dining with delivery to your table after you place the order. The ice cream selection is huge and it really brings the crowds after dinner hour. Parking is plentiful and of course free. They offer a mini golf cours...
Mountville
Scoops Ice Cream & Grille
4.6
(591 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Located near a great hotel this little restaurant really rocks. They feature outdoor dining with delivery to your table after you place the order. The ice cream selection is huge and it really brings the crowds after dinner hour. Parking is plentiful and of course free. They offer a mini golf cours...
Mountville
Masonic Village Farm Market
4.7
(272 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"The market has a large selection of fresh vegetables and fruits, especially apples, you can buy pastries for every taste, homemade flowers and spices, and some souvenirs. The price, as it breaks down in such a crowded place, is a little higher, but the choice is up to you."...
Elizabethtown
Campus Ridge Farm Market
4.7
(272 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"The market has a large selection of fresh vegetables and fruits, especially apples, you can buy pastries for every taste, homemade flowers and spices, and some souvenirs. The price, as it breaks down in such a crowded place, is a little higher, but the choice is up to you." - лариса п....
Elizabethtown
Udder Bliss Creamery
4.6
(301 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Family oriented ice cream experience in a parking lot for what looks like an agway-type place. Tucked away neatly, you can find your way and see all the goodness that lies therein. The ice cream is superb and the flavor options are fantastic. My favorite has been (Irish Creme, Coconut, Lavender hon...
Elizabethtown
This list is ranked based on reviews & ratings data. Learn more about how we rank businesses by reading our ranking methodology.
If you'd prefer to see top-rated businesses in Lancaster County by location, take a look at our map.