The Lanc Local team analyzed 19,817 local reviews and metrics to find the best bakeries Maytown, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Bakeries
Near Maytown, PA
Cake Creators
5
(87 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"We’ve been using Cake Creators for our family birthday cakes ever since we moved to the area in 2019. The cakes are always so nicely decorated and do yummy! Our guests always comment on how delicious they are. Patty is so sweet and always so accommodating!" - M. Salador...
Lancaster
The Flour Child
4.8
(124 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I am taking the time to write a review for this fantastic bakery. Not only is it was the cake stunning, and a work of art in itself, but it was absolutely delicious and the hit of the party! The owner was so friendly and helpful at pickup. I will be a repeat customer and made many recommendations i...
Columbia
Made With Love Not Gluten Bakery
4.8
(183 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"This bakery offers coconut milk for coffee, which is great. They also have GF pizza crusts, macaroni, and other non sweet items in a freezer for purchase."...
Mount Joy
Made With Love Not Gluten Bakery
4.8
(178 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"This place is amazing! They are my GO TO bakery when ordering custom cakes! Their cakes are delicious, ordering the cakes is SUPER simple. I had ONE mishap where the computer system didn’t take my order, not sure what happened there however technology issues happen all the time HOWEVER! Their bak...
Mount Joy
Rise Bake Shoppe and Coffee Bar
4.8
(178 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"This place is amazing! They are my GO TO bakery when ordering custom cakes! Their cakes are delicious, ordering the cakes is SUPER simple. I had ONE mishap where the computer system didn’t take my order, not sure what happened there however technology issues happen all the time HOWEVER! Their bak...
Mount Joy
Columbia Market House
4.7
(139 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"They have the freshest produce and the best sweet corn. We drive up from MD for strawberries, corn, cantaloupe, and fresh cut flowers! In the fall they have the best prices on mums with many different colors" - Jessica B....
Columbia
Rolling Gardens Farm Market
4.7
(139 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"They have the freshest produce and the best sweet corn. We drive up from MD for strawberries, corn, cantaloupe, and fresh cut flowers! In the fall they have the best prices on mums with many different colors"...
Columbia
Central Manor Bakery & Grille
4.5
(305 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Clean place, friendly staff. The cherry pie was one of the best I’ve ever eaten. Cookies, cakes, brownies, and pies that all looked delicious and fresh. I will definitely stop again."...
Lancaster
Shady Acres Farm Market
4.8
(83 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Ice cream, organic and seasonal produce, meat from the farm, and prepared food! Soups, pies, breads, sandwiches made to order and a small coffee shop inside as well. I really love their no sugar added apple butter and their homemade ketchup, especially the black pepper one. Flavored honey sticks, l...
Elizabethtown
Masonic Village Farm Market
4.8
(83 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Ice cream, organic and seasonal produce, meat from the farm, and prepared food! Soups, pies, breads, sandwiches made to order and a small coffee shop inside as well. I really love their no sugar added apple butter and their homemade ketchup, especially the black pepper one. Flavored honey sticks, l...
Elizabethtown
This list is ranked based on reviews & ratings data. Learn more about how we rank businesses by reading our ranking methodology.
If you'd prefer to see top-rated businesses in Lancaster County by location, take a look at our map.