The Lanc Local team analyzed 4,205 local reviews and metrics to find the best wedding cake bakeries Lancaster, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Wedding Cake Bakeries
Near Lancaster, PA
Sunnyside Pastries
4.8
(366 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We were on a road trip through Lancaster County and drove past this fabulous pastry shop so we quickly made a u-turn to check it out and we're so glad we did!!
They have a huge selection of fresh pastries and the young woman that helped us was so sweet and informed.
They have donuts, past...
East Earl
Torres Family Bakery LLC
4.6
(649 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great local bakery! The shop is small, but the food is grand . The bakery items are delicious, and the empanadas are great. They also have custom cakes to order as well, and sandwiches. There's a lot to offer in this little cute shop.
We got some pastries, and they are delicious and fresh. Defi...
Lancaster
Cake Creators
5
(87 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We’ve been using Cake Creators for our family birthday cakes ever since we moved to the area in 2019. The cakes are always so nicely decorated and do yummy! Our guests always comment on how delicious they are. Patty is so sweet and always so accommodating!" - M. Salador...
Lancaster
The Flour Child
4.8
(124 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I am taking the time to write a review for this fantastic bakery. Not only is it was the cake stunning, and a work of art in itself, but it was absolutely delicious and the hit of the party! The owner was so friendly and helpful at pickup. I will be a repeat customer and made many recommendations i...
Columbia
Sweet Shenanigans Cupcakery
4.9
(84 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've ordered from Sweet Shenanigans several times, large orders and also a few just to take and home and share with my boys. My favorites are her unique flavors you don't find at other bakeries. I recently served the lemon drop and simply strawberry cupcakes at a baby shower. So many of the guests ...
Gordonville
Salt & Light Pastry Co.
5
(47 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Working with Ruby was an abs.lute joy! I was planning my wedding from across the country- which made it impossible for me to taste the cake ahead of time, but Ruby does the overnight shipping - s. I got to taste from afar!
I gave her full creative freedom as to how she wanted to decorate the cup...
Lancaster
Byers Butterflake Bakery
4.6
(96 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Byer's has been a staple for getting cakes for special occasions from over the years. They've made a cake for my high school graduation, one for my graduate school commencement, and just recently a gorgeous cake for my friend's baby shower. I even had tried their cupcakes! The service is immaculate...
Leola
Valosh pâtisserie
4.9
(49 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I did a Macaron class with Valeria and I now feel confident enough to make them at home! She is very welcoming and a great teacher. We had so much fun and learned a lot. She demonstrated first while we asked questions and took notes. Then we each got to try the recipe on our own and she was there t...
Elizabethtown
Rosie’s Creative Cakes
4.9
(41 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We booked Rosie for our wedding cake, and we are so glad that we did! We wanted a simple two-tier cake. Oh my word. It was to die for! The booking process was so simple. We did opt for an at-home tasting due to covid, but it was still so much fun! We will be ordering from her again!" - J. Cole...
Manheim
