The Lanc Local team analyzed 959 local reviews and metrics to find the best property management companies Lancaster, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Property Management Companies
Near Lancaster, PA
Wolf & Kline Property Management Inc
3.9
(601 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The maintenance group here at Wolf and Kline is wonderful! Anytime I have an issue they resolve it in a timely manner! I was having trouble with the hot water being Luke warm, so the plumber came out and found that the hot water heater was leaking. Once repaired it is as good as new again! Thank yo...
Lititz
City Limits Realty
3.8
(42 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Pay your rent on time & you'll have no trouble however if you're renting a garage they will fix the issue very quickly the only issue I had was other renters using spaces in front of garage doors fixing there cars on jack stands which made it impossible to get into my garage. I recorded a video of ...
Lancaster
Trinity Real Estate
3.7
(27 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My wife and I have been renters for some time, and Trinity has been our best experience with a management company by far.
Specifically, it has been the demeanor and responsiveness of Jim Bushong, who does everything from handling agreements to making repairs. He has been a friendly presence who is...
Lancaster
Alpha Property Management
4.7
(3 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Me and my wife used Phil as our real estate agent multiple times, it has gone flawless everytime. Profesional and responsive. Highly recommend to anyone!" - Zach S....
East Petersburg
Our Town Leasing
3.7
(7 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Rented with them for about a year as they took over our building. They were very understanding and helpful with any issues. Figured out and fixed them, got things done. Didn't over charge me during a vacate move out, were willing to be lenient and helpful throughout during a very rough time for mys...
Lancaster
Crossroads Property Management Inc.
3.1
(38 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I been with Crossroads for almost 15 yrs . Brian has worked with me threw my situation in time of need . He has work me with threw hard time, making sure my family has a stable home . He is reasonable person to work with. I'm very grateful and very appreciative with him. Thank you very much , keepi...
Lancaster
Magnolia Lane Properties
2.4
(57 Reviews)
Featured review:
"After we lost our home and belongings in a fire on 6/2/23, we thought we would be living in a hotel forever! We have a pitbull, who thinks he is a lap dog and no one would rent to us! We looked at many properties our insurance company found for us that would accept dogs and none of them were safe f...
Quarryville
American Heritage Property Management
2.4
(184 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Worked with Penny Falcon for the last 2 years before property got sold. She made the whole process very easy for us. Worked with us. And just has been amazing through our whole experience. Any issues with maintenance or anything Penny got it done. Thank you for everything! Highly recommend Penny!" ...
Lancaster