The Lanc Local team analyzed over 37,200 local reviews and metrics to find the best ice cream shops Lancaster, PA has to offer.
Enjoy!
Top ice cream shops in the Lancaster, PA area
LOCALS’ CHOICE
Pine View Dairy
4.8
/5 rating
(
1561
reviews)
“Beautiful! I was able to get some snickerdoodle cookies, which taste delicious. The handmade ice cream was very tasty & I love the quality of the milk. Great store overall.”…
chocolate milk
strawberry milk
Lancaster
LOCALS’ CHOICE
Nikki’s Custard
5
/5 rating
(
91
reviews)
“The research is done! The verdict is in! Nikki’s Custard brings a classic from the Midwest to Lancaster Pennsylvania. After you try what homemade frozen custard is like, you will never go back to ice…
sorbet
vanilla custard
Lancaster
LOCALS’ CHOICE
Lapp Valley Farm
4.9
/5 rating
(
2400
reviews)
“When we visit Lancaster we always stop here. This location is the actual farm, they have the best homemade ice cream, milk, butter. If you’re like us we traveled a couple hours to get here we always …
chocolate milk
waffle cones
New Holland
