Best Consignment Stores in Lancaster, PA [Ranked by Locals]

The Lanc Local team analyzed over 8,400 local reviews and metrics to find the best consignment stores Lancaster has to offer.

Enjoy!

Top consignment stores in the Lancaster, PA area

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Next to New Fine Clothing LLC.

4.8

/5 rating

(

39

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Once Mine Boutique

4.7

/5 rating

(

101

reviews)

East Earl

More Information

LOCALS’ CHOICE

Ali Witman Consignments

4.9

/5 rating

(

36

reviews)

Lititz

More Information

Full list of consignment stores in the Lancaster, PA area

Ooh La La Consignment

4.6

/5 rating

(

45

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Plato’s Closet Lancaster

3.6

/5 rating

(

443

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Fashion Cents Bargain Bins

4

/5 rating

(

40

reviews)

East Earl

More Information

Hear & Now

4.3

/5 rating

(

90

reviews)

Elizabethtown

More Information

BFR Consignment Shops

/5 rating

(

reviews)

Denver

More Information

Divine Consign

4.3

/5 rating

(

57

reviews)

Manheim

More Information

Shop Eight 16 Consignment LLC

5

/5 rating

(

10

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Miracles Consignment Shop

4.6

/5 rating

(

51

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Twice Found Resale Boutique

4.5

/5 rating

(

22

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Abundant Treasures

3.4

/5 rating

(

13

reviews)

Ephrata

More Information

Once Mine Boutique

4.7

/5 rating

(

101

reviews)

East Earl

More Information

Next to New Fine Clothing LLC.

4.8

/5 rating

(

39

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Little Bo-Tique Family Consignment Shop

4.4

/5 rating

(

67

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Pass It On! Consignment

4.5

/5 rating

(

73

reviews)

Ephrata

More Information

Fancy Unicorn

4.8

/5 rating

(

17

reviews)

Elizabethtown

More Information

Waltman’s Hidden Treasures

4.5

/5 rating

(

44

reviews)

Quarryville

More Information

Ali Witman Consignments

4.9

/5 rating

(

36

reviews)

Lititz

More Information

The Exchange Consignment Boutique

4.9

/5 rating

(

16

reviews)

Lititz

More Information

Next To New Fine Furniture

4.4

/5 rating

(

247

reviews)

Lancaster

More Information

Purple Turtle Consignment Boutique

4.6

/5 rating

(

58

reviews)

Lititz

More Information

Deja Vu Consignment Boutique

4.7

/5 rating

(

23

reviews)

Landisville

More Information

The Fashion Exchange

4.4

/5 rating

(

17

reviews)

Quarryville

More Information

Twice But Nice consignment store

4

/5 rating

(

6

reviews)

Ephrata

More Information

Fashion Cents Consignment – Ephrata

4.4

/5 rating

(

354

reviews)

Ephrata

More Information

Fashion Cents Consignment – Strasburg

4.3

/5 rating

(

358

reviews)

Strasburg

More Information

Wearhouse Consignment

3.9

/5 rating

(

51

reviews)

Salunga-Landisville

More Information

Barely Used Resale Boutique

4.3

/5 rating

(

146

reviews)

Mount Joy

More Information

Closet 2 Closet Boutique

5

/5 rating

(

6

reviews)

Stevens

More Information