The Lanc Local team analyzed 6,915 local reviews and metrics to find the best insurance agencies Kinzers, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Insurance Agencies
Near Kinzers, PA
Valerie Stocker – State Farm Insurance Agent
5
(130 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very professional, very personable, excellent customer service and communication skills. Very compassionate to a life situation and understanding. Was very efficient, fast work the help I needed. I've never had such a pleasurable experience with any insurance companies that I've worked with. I will...
Strasburg
Unruh Insurance Agency, Inc.
4.9
(132 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Katie has been very helped and pays attention to details that other insurance companies did not. She has helped my parents and myself get the best coverage out there. And is only a short phonecall away if we find we need to make a change. She is very professional and always gets back to us in a tim...
East Earl
Benner Insurance Agency
4.9
(96 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Where do I even begin! This is insurance company is a go to for all commercial, personal, life and more. I started with Lamar and was covered with my brick and mortar. Lamar was so passionate not only in his expertise but knowing me as a customer. He has gone above and beyond to assure great rates....
Strasburg
McGowan Insurance Agency
4.8
(67 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Carrie was very helpful and friendly. She took care of my needs and made me feel like a member of the family. I will recommend Erie to everyone I know." - Don W....
Quarryville
Goodville Mutual Casualty Company
4.2
(299 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I had an unfortunate deer collision in December 2023. I called the toll free number from the side of the road and was immediately relieved to speak with a live human who calmly advised me. I was contacted soon after by a claim specialist who helped me through the process. Goodville paid the initial...
New Holland
Good’s Insurance Agency
4.5
(44 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excellent Insurance Broker. As a small trucking company we are pleased to work with such a company. Jennifer is always on top of things and communicates exceptionally with us." - Christal B....
Leola
All Types Insurance
5
(22 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very delightful to work with they are always willing to help you any which way they can. And they always have a smile on their face." - Bob J....
Quarryville
Beiler Insurance Agency
4.5
(37 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I’ve been with Beiler Insurance for years + there is truly no other insurance agency out there that is better than them. Their customer service is top tier, and really, what more would you want from an insurance agency than that?!?
Dianne takes the most amazing care of her clients. I never have ...
Gap
Landis Heritage Insurance
4.9
(16 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have been doing business with this company for several years. I have no complaints. They are always helpful. The rates & insurance are better than any other I've found since moving to this area." - Kathleen M....
Quarryville
Weaver Insurance Associates
4.7
(15 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We had storm damage to several fields. Our agent came out with the adjuster and advocated for us. We didn’t have to ask him to come. He arranged it so he was there. It’s so nice to know your agent doesn’t just care getting your business. He cared that we got what was right for the damage we h...
Strasburg