The Lanc Local team analyzed 67,003 local reviews and metrics to find the best pizza restaurants Elizabethtown, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Pizza Restaurants
Near Elizabethtown, PA
Bellia’s Pizza II Elizabethtown
4.9
(136 Reviews)
Featured review:
"If we were judging by the food* alone (which is phenomenal btw) I'd give full marks. But, the hospitality and good vibes I experienced last night (March 21/2024) with this crew... just stellar! I sure wish I lived nearby so I could visit every week. Please come South guys, we need a Bellia's in the...
Elizabethtown
DiMaria’s NY Pizza and Italian Restaurant
4.6
(350 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Really good pizza for a good price. I doubt that there is a better pizza place in the area.
I do not try other pizza places because I am happy to keep eating from here.
I've gotten a few subs and they were good, not great. The pizza is the real star.
I got the garlic knots and they weren't as go...
Mount Joy
Two Cousin’s Pizza & Italian
4.4
(310 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've been eating at the Mount Joy Two Cousin's for over 30 years and have never had one complaint. The staff is very friendly and attentive. I always have a great meal here. Their Cheeseburger sub is the best I have ever had! They also have great pizza, appetizers and milkshakes."...
Mount Joy
Columbia Pizza Restaurant
4.4
(288 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I got two slices of plain cheese pizza to go in my car, it ruled. There are million pizza places that have italian sounding names that are decent but these guys deliver on that flavor. Only rating 4 stars for atmosphere cause if you want a 5 star in house experience for mostly take out pizza you're...
Columbia
Babbo’s Pizza
4.3
(556 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Call ahead, and the drive-thru for pizza is outstanding! Super fast. The staff is kind and ready to help you. Everything I've ever eaten there was wonderful. I've taken guest there, and they thought it was worth revisiting more often. They liked the food! Try it, you won't be disappointed."...
Elizabethtown
Today’s Pizza & Mamma Rita Italian Restaurant
4.3
(356 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My wife and I walk into this treasure of restaurant dinning, and take out, we just move to the Lancaster area a couple years ago, and we where having difficulty finding a Italian restaurant that serves our favorite foods, with great customer service, fair prices, and most of all! Great food!!! That...
Mount Joy
Domino’s Pizza
4.3
(282 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I walked in placed an order for a medium pizza within 10 minutes it was done and delivered. I brought it home and was met with unexpectedly possibly the greatest Pizza I had ever consumed. It outclassed every other Pizza I have had in my entire life. I did not expect this level of deliciousness to ...
Columbia
Marietta Pizza and Grill
4.3
(251 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We purchased one of the garlic knot, mozzarella stick, pepperoni pizza in the shape of a heart for Valentine’s Day. I saw the advertisement on Facebook for it and it instantly had my mouth watering!! It looked great!! We received ours and as soon as I got to the car I thought it smelled amazing!!...
Marietta
My Place Italian Restaurant
4.3
(199 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We have ordered here for months (takeout) and have always been happy with the deliciousness of their food. We finally dined in today and the food was excellent! If you haven’t tried them, give them a try. Their authentic Mexican food is off the hook! Their huaraches are pictured and are great! I ...
Elizabethtown
Sicilia Pizza Marietta
4.4
(36 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Fantastic slices! Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Very nice staff and atmosphere. I will definitely be returning "...
Marietta