The Lanc Local team analyzed 361 local reviews and metrics to find the best novelty stores Conestoga, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Novelty Stores
Near Conestoga, PA
Madcap & Co.
4.7
(95 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great place and cute local gift shop in Lancaster! I've lived here for a while now and finally went here for the first time, and was glad I did. They have a lot of neat products, and great for gifts. And the shop is pretty big! Definitely recommend checking it out!!" - David N....
Lancaster
BoxLunch
4.7
(47 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Shopped around with my bestie and got some snacks. Joel was very very friendly. We joked around with him and had a very good time. 10/10 would go again" - tori s....
Lancaster
Norman’s Hallmark Shop
4.6
(59 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Ashley is truly the best, most incredible sales associate you’ve ever had, She explained the points system I’ve had for years, but I never knew I was accruing points or bonuses on and she saved me almost 5 dollars today. She was absolutely incredible and deserves a job. Well done for excellent ...
Lancaster
Norman’s Hallmark Shop
4.3
(85 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I bought a clock that I ended up having to exchange twice because it didn’t work, but the employees of the Belmont location were MORE than helpful in finding me a model that worked and following up with me to make sure my issue was resolved. I haven’t experienced customer service like that in a...
Lancaster
Centerville Cardtique
4.2
(51 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Heather, Kelly, Lavonne are my people. I love going into thos store b/c u can find unique gifts plus the staff in this store is top notch." - M “....
Lancaster
Kendig Cardtique
4.1
(24 Reviews)
Featured review:
"So much to choose from and cashiers are always nice and helpful." - LeAnn K....
Willow Street