The Lanc Local team analyzed 6,915 local reviews and metrics to find the best insurance agencies Conestoga, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Insurance Agencies
Near Conestoga, PA
Sean Kelleher – State Farm Insurance Agent
5
(363 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Sean is very helpful and was able to help us when we were in a rut. Very reliable and professional. He took his time to work with us. I highly recommend working with him!" - Kaylin C....
Lancaster
HomeSale Insurance Services
5
(329 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I worked with Mr. Lee Roe. He was very quick with replies, prompt and efficient with his paperwork, and he saved me alot of money with my car insurance. I'm paying half of what I was previously paying. He was so thorough, I am referring him to everyone who will listen. He is fixing up my daughter...
Lancaster
Forbes Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance
5
(153 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Thank you very much Leslie for my new police's you saved me a lot of money. It will be great working with you if I have any problems. Great service and very friendly and helpful. Thanks again!! New customer" - Jeff T....
Lancaster
Susquehanna Insurance
4.9
(198 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I love working with the team at Susquehanna Insurance and I'm always referring friends. Angie is my agent and is very responsive to emails, friendly and knowledgeable. My family has several auto insurance policies with Susquehanna and have made a lot of changes recently. Angie and Miriam respon...
Lancaster
Valerie Stocker – State Farm Insurance Agent
5
(130 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very professional, very personable, excellent customer service and communication skills. Very compassionate to a life situation and understanding. Was very efficient, fast work the help I needed. I've never had such a pleasurable experience with any insurance companies that I've worked with. I will...
Strasburg
Bagnall Shaw Insurance
4.7
(282 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have been a satisfied customer with Bagnall Shaw for 2 years so far. They were able to give me the absolute best rate on my car insurance when I started shopping 2 years ago when I bought my vehicle. Last year, Garrett even contacted me when my year of car insurance was close to renewal to tell m...
Lancaster
Red Rose Insurance
5
(93 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My lender recommended Red Rose when I was purchasing my first house. Ben found me a policy at a cheaper rate than I was able to find in my own. He made the process easy and even helped me get a better rate on my car insurance." - Jess C....
Lancaster
Eagle One Insurance Agency
5
(92 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Argumentatively one of the best by far Agencies that you could call for services. Not only will they express everything to your comfort level but you will leave feeling as if you were in the best of hands. Thanks for my commercial insurance and the time you took to help us. Well deserved review!!!"...
Lancaster
Gebhard Insurance LLC
4.9
(109 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The girls in the office are very sweet and kind.They were very helpful. I received a great quote with better coverage!! Would highly recommend Gebhard Insurance to anyone looking for great insurance with a great price!" - Danielle T....
Lancaster
Aika Bodnar – State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9
(108 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Aika and her staff are knowledgeable, efficient---and even more importantly---polite and helpful. They address your insurance needs and concerns with respect. I'm very fortunate to have found them shortly after I arrived in Lancaster! Thanks!" - Brian d....
Lancaster