Best Ice Cream Shops Near Conestoga, PA [Ranked by Locals]
Lanc Local analyzed 34,630
local reviews and metrics to find the best Ice Cream Shops
Lancaster, PA has to offer.
We're a team of locals, all born and raised in Lancaster County. Our mission is to provide unbiased rankings of all businesses and attractions in Lancaster County. To do this, we base our rankings not just our own experiences, but on the testimonials of over a million locals and visitors. We rank according to reviews, category, location, and aggregated Lanc Local data comparing customer interactions vs. all other similar businesses and attractions for this locale. Learn more about our ranking methodology.
Top Ice Cream Shops
Near Conestoga, PA
The
Ice Cream Shops
below are listed according to our rankings, starting with the highest-ranked Ice Cream Shops
first.
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe
4.9
(578 Reviews)
Featured review:
"They have the best ice cream that I have ever had anywhere in my life. Ice cream in fancy ice creameries at shops or stores, or even "Amish made" is nowhere close to their taste and quality. Let's not forget their drinks, well made and give no acne. Prices, good. Very fair and worth it." -...
Pine View Dairy
4.8
(1,561 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Beautiful! I was able to get some snickerdoodle cookies, which taste delicious. The handmade ice cream was very tasty & I love the quality of the milk. Great store overall."...
Rolled Cold Creamery – Lancaster
4.8
(861 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Really fun place! It’s cool to watch them make the ice-cream right in front of you. We got the espresso coffee flavor - can definitely recommend it. It comes off REALLY cold, so be careful not to freeze your tongue! It’s a little pricey but the good news is, me and my wife shared a regular an...
Down On The Farm Creamery
4.9
(805 Reviews)
Featured review:
"An off the road Amish creamery with the most decadent hand made ice cream I've ever had. The views are of the hills and farm are a calming backdrop. The animals, esp the babies make for a fun visit as well. Play area for kids allows parents to relax."...
Splits and Giggles Cafe
4.7
(425 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great tasting ice cream. I wasn't expecting the soup of the day, but they had one and it didn't disappoint. The lady at the counter was friendly and patient. We had a large-ish order and some of the kids changed their minds mid order. Good experience overall. As of the date of this post there is co...
Forry’s Country Store
4.8
(568 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Forry's is my happy place!!! The staff is so nice and so are the customers.There are so many goodies in this little store.My favorites are the fresh made subs and different cheeses. Really great prices.Thank you for always making it a great experience every time I visit."...
Strasburg Creamery, Café, and Country Store
4.6
(1,161 Reviews)
Featured review:
"A heartwarming experience today the girls there were so incredibly sweet and just pushing through the Sunday rush! Unfortunately I had made a mistake and didn’t realize they couldn’t take Apple Pay (again my mistake completely I should have asked!) they girls were so sweet, and just allowed m...
Down on the Farm Creamery
4.6
(1,161 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I absolutely love their ice and I always get the strawberry. However, the last time I got it (about 2 weeks ago) there were no strawberries in the ice cream. Not one. It was still delicious but really missed the strawberries." - Terri G....
Nikki’s Custard
5
(91 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The research is done! The verdict is in! Nikki's Custard brings a classic from the Midwest to Lancaster Pennsylvania. After you try what homemade frozen custard is like, you will never go back to ice cream. It is healthier, more natural, and a staple when it comes to desserts in the Midwest. I cann...
Scoops Ice Cream & Grille
4.6
(591 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Located near a great hotel this little restaurant really rocks. They feature outdoor dining with delivery to your table after you place the order. The ice cream selection is huge and it really brings the crowds after dinner hour. Parking is plentiful and of course free. They offer a mini golf cours...
