The Lanc Local team analyzed 4,273 local reviews and metrics to find the best gift shops Conestoga, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Gift Shops
Near Conestoga, PA
BUiLDiNG CHARACTER
4.7
(728 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Stepping into this antique store is like taking a journey back in time. Each piece tells a story, and the variety is simply astounding. From vintage furniture that whispers tales of the past to unique collectibles that spark curiosity, there's an endless treasure trove to explore. The atmosphere is...
Lancaster
Good’s Store
4.6
(1,392 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great store! Just learned that my grandmother shopped there back in the day, my dad is a regular, and I will definitely be keeping the tradition." - Gardening w....
Quarryville
Ace of Vapes, LLC
4.8
(153 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The morning staff member Nick is awesome! I’ve been going to Columbia Ave store for a while, and he knows what I want when walking in the door. NOMS White Peach Ras 24.
Job Well Done!" - Wenona P....
Lancaster
Lush Cosmetics Park City Center
4.7
(208 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The workers here are soooo sweet and friendly. I hadn’t been in a LUSH store in years, and they were very helpful giving me the rundown on their current products.
I picked up a bath bomb, and the cashier, Bex/Becks also offered me a sample of a fresh face mask. They also threw in a set of eye pa...
Lancaster
Lancaster Brewing Company Taproom & Grill
4.4
(1,372 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This was a recommendation by a local for dinner.
Our waitress, Sydney was superb and attentive to all our needs.,She helped with sample beer drinks so we could get it right. The food was excellent and now I know I love a milk stout!"...
Lancaster
Christmas Tree Hill
4.6
(153 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Absolutely love this place. The atmosphere you feel as soon as you step into the store just hits differently. If you like decorating and are as big into decorating for the holidays as I am you have to check it out" - TOUGH C....
Lancaster
Books-A-Million
4.4
(588 Reviews)
Featured review:
"It's great to have an option for buying books that allows you to pick up and page through it. So much of our purchases are online now but I needed to buy a children's book and wanted the option to actually see it before buying and look through it for content. This store has a good variety of select...
Lancaster
Royer’s Flowers & Gifts
4.6
(136 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I walked into Royer’s on a whim to see about making little bouquets for my parent’s anniversary that day. The associate was so friendly and helpful in listening to what I wanted, as well as adding what she thought would work. She put together 2 amazing daisy bouquets that I could not have done ...
Lancaster
Madcap & Co.
4.7
(95 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great place and cute local gift shop in Lancaster! I've lived here for a while now and finally went here for the first time, and was glad I did. They have a lot of neat products, and great for gifts. And the shop is pretty big! Definitely recommend checking it out!!" - David N....
Lancaster
Disney Store
4.4
(447 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I extremely enjoyed my visit. Very polite,and very reasonable prices. Haven't been in a Disney store in a long time I thought they shut them all down but I'm really glad this one is still around very nostalgic and miss it. I had a great experience especially because the parks are so far away" - Mic...
Lancaster