The Lanc Local team analyzed 51,501 local reviews and metrics to find the best car dealers Conestoga, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Car Dealers
Near Conestoga, PA
Lancaster Toyota
4.8
(2,387 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Rolando took time to understand my requirements and preferences, and he expertly guided me towards the perfect car that met all my needs. He was never pushy and always ensured that I had all the information necessary to make an informed decision.
Throughout the entire process, Rolando was profes...
East Petersburg
Lancaster County Motors Subaru
4.7
(2,533 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I always have such a pleasant experience here. They are fast, efficient, and very kind! The express lane is wonderful for general service. The seating area inside is perfect to relax or work remotely while waiting for service to be done. They are honest and upfront. I don’t know too much about ca...
Lancaster
Lancaster Hyundai
4.7
(1,837 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I love them, the salesman Chris was able to get me the SUV that I wanted. The are staff was great, warming and inviting. The financial guy was professional but entertaining. They made us feel like family. Thank you to the entire staff." - Sam I....
East Petersburg
Faulkner BMW of Lancaster
4.7
(1,505 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Bought my car from out of state. Robert Howry and the team of BMW of Lancaster did an awesome job. Very fair and straightforward to work with. Communication and prompt responses. Also had a BMW tech expert help me at pick up to get the most out of the tech. They even answer my follow up questions m...
Lancaster
Enterprise Car Sales
4.8
(375 Reviews)
Featured review:
"From the time we walked into the showroom everyone was so nice. We felt lucky to get Stefhan for our salesperson. He was helpful, informative, and very nice. He eventually found the right car for us, answered all our questions and helped us with all the paperwork as well as some other online docume...
East Petersburg
Mercedes-Benz of Lancaster
4.7
(1,352 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I had a very positive experience here.
Ben handled the transaction in a very comfortable and not aggressive way.
The entire team here is top notch, extremely knowledgeable and made everything very easy. From the finance manager to the service team to the awesome lady who set up my technology an...
East Petersburg
Lancaster Kia
4.7
(969 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Got a screw caught in my tire in the middle of the night, didn’t have a spare so I had my Kia towed to this dealership immediately after. Rachel & staff were friendly and efficient. As busy as I’m sure they were tending to other customers who had appointments, they were still able to accommodat...
East Petersburg
Providence Autos CDJR
4.6
(522 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Hank was wonderful. He started the truck as we walked towards it, has remote start on a diesel! Hank was familiar with the vehicle, was not put off by our offer and agreed it was a reasonable offer for the items that needed attention that my wife pointed out. And he stayed after closing to finish t...
Quarryville
C & D MotorSports
4.6
(383 Reviews)
Featured review:
"10/10 Recommend this car dealership to anyone that doesn’t like getting finessed or pressured while buying a car. We went too 7 different lots and C&D is by far the best in many ways, Nice/Clean cars, Great Prices, And even better service. I was greeted at the door by Chris and immediately felt l...
Lancaster
Sauder Motors
4.8
(133 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My wife and I just purchased a 2017 BMW X3 from Jay, and the dealership. I have been buying and selling cars for over 20 years, and I must say this was one of, if not the best experiences I have ever had at a dealership. This dealer was very laid-back, completely without pressure, and did everythin...
Strasburg