The Lanc Local team analyzed 53,597 local reviews and metrics to find the best italian restaurants Columbia, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Italian Restaurants
Near Columbia, PA
Little Italy Italian Restaurant
4.6
(551 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Must stop, great price, excellent portions. You can not find prices like this in the city, so if you're driving through, hit this up. The only problem is you will be too full and not comfortable. Only had pizza, but the pasta looked good also."...
Bainbridge
DiMaria’s NY Pizza and Italian Restaurant
4.6
(350 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Really good pizza for a good price. I doubt that there is a better pizza place in the area.
I do not try other pizza places because I am happy to keep eating from here.
I've gotten a few subs and they were good, not great. The pizza is the real star.
I got the garlic knots and they weren't as go...
Mount Joy
Caruso’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza Shop
4.5
(504 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have always loved this carusos! The food is great! I just used them for my baby shower. We did full trays of pasta and salad. You can’t beat the price for how much food we got. I was getting quoted 300-600.0 at other places for catering for only 25 people. Carusos by far had the best pricing & ...
Lancaster
Bacio Pizza Italian Grill
4.6
(243 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I didn't have very high expectations given the experience I have had away from local restaurants, but I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the cheessteak I ordered. The cheesesteak was well prepared. delicious, meaty, and flavorful. The bread was top quality with the right level of crustin...
Manheim
Randazzo’s
4.5
(435 Reviews)
Featured review:
"First time eating here, and the staff was so great. The gentleman that took our order laughed and joked with us and answered questions with ease. The food was really good. Hot and fresh and well flavored. Definitely will eat here again when in the area."...
Manheim
Nino’s New York Style Pizza
4.5
(374 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Best pizza I’ve had period. It’s home for me. The chicken tenders are great as well. Love the employees as well. The plain cheese hits like nowhere else. My favorite is the Margarita here. If you’re thinking or looking on these reviews to find good pizza.. then just go here and be happy"...
Lancaster
Gargano’s Pizzeria & Deli
4.6
(171 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Wow, I’m not one to write reviews a lot, but that pizza was perfect. (Literally writing this 20 minutes after eating a slice…)
If you’re looking for something you would get in New York City, this is the place to go. Delicious!!"...
East Petersburg
Venice Pizza and Pasta
4.4
(641 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We picked up food here and it was great! We got pizza and cheese fries. The pizza was very fresh and premium, and the fries were great. They also have adult slushies ❤️
The atmosphere was like a traditional pizza shop feel, and they a decent amount of seating.
We really enjoy this local p...
Lancaster
Two Cousins Pizza Millersville
4.4
(322 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My husband and I stopped here for the first time because I told him I wanted authentic pizza hahaha. Well let me tell you they did not disappoint. Got the small self size pizza and yes soo good. I did get the wings too and they were just okay, nothing wrong with them, just not my kind of wings. I...
Millersville
Two Cousin’s Pizza & Italian
4.4
(310 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've been eating at the Mount Joy Two Cousin's for over 30 years and have never had one complaint. The staff is very friendly and attentive. I always have a great meal here. Their Cheeseburger sub is the best I have ever had! They also have great pizza, appetizers and milkshakes."...
Mount Joy