The Lanc Local team analyzed 19,817 local reviews and metrics to find the best bakeries Christiana, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Bakeries
Near Christiana, PA
Immergut Hand-Rolled Soft Pretzels
4.8
(0 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Visited two weeks ago and can’t stop thinking about these pretzels. So good!" - M. van Oers...
Intercourse
Stoltzfus Meats
4.7
(831 Reviews)
Featured review:
"The Stltzfus store is a store like no other that I have been in. They have a deli style restaurant inside with a very nice menu.
The meat case has the most amazing steaks, chicken and other fresh meat. My Wife and I always take a cooler with us when shopping at this store."...
Intercourse
Locally Made Food Shop
4.8
(172 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Everyone needs to stop here! About 3 years ago I was taking this route on the way to Hershey's and I noticed the little shop in the curve. I wonder to myself exactly what they sold since they apparently had a retail sales area. Fast forward and I was driving again to Hershey today and there It was ...
Strasburg
Michael’s Homestyle Breads
4.8
(172 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Everyone needs to stop here! About 3 years ago I was taking this route on the way to Hershey's and I noticed the little shop in the curve. I wonder to myself exactly what they sold since they apparently had a retail sales area. Fast forward and I was driving again to Hershey today and there It was ...
Strasburg
The bake shop
4.7
(217 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We LOVE these cookies. It is true that they are big so we typically divide them but they are absolutely superior to other cookie places around. I wish they would make it down into the Philadelphia area but I know people in the Lancaster area so visit often. I just noticed the chocolate covered stra...
Gordonville
Taylor Chip Cookies
4.7
(217 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We LOVE these cookies. It is true that they are big so we typically divide them but they are absolutely superior to other cookie places around. I wish they would make it down into the Philadelphia area but I know people in the Lancaster area so visit often. I just noticed the chocolate covered stra...
Gordonville
Sweet Shenanigans Cupcakery
4.9
(84 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I've ordered from Sweet Shenanigans several times, large orders and also a few just to take and home and share with my boys. My favorites are her unique flavors you don't find at other bakeries. I recently served the lemon drop and simply strawberry cupcakes at a baby shower. So many of the guests ...
Gordonville
Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery
4.4
(1,671 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Dutch Haven is a kitschy Americana paradise (read: haven) in the heart of Amish country. We were both treated with a sample of shoo-fly pie upon entering, which of course, was the reason for our visit. However, the interesting, old building is worth the visit alone.
In addition to regional confe...
Ronks
M&A Sweet Treats
4.9
(59 Reviews)
Featured review:
"If you come to this area must try donuts here. Very nice place to have fresh hand made donuts. One of my friend visited and recommended me to go their. I went there to get donuts. The stuffs are friendly. They allow us to come inside and see."...
Ronks
Locally Made Food Shop
4.7
(70 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Super cute shop! A lot of it is not Amish made which we didn’t know but still good! We got the red apple balsamic, homemade Cheetos, blueberry bread, honey white bread, black raspberry jam, chocolate covered pretzel and coffee. Everything tasted great! The workers were very friendly and it was a ...
Ronks