The Lanc Local team analyzed 6,915 local reviews and metrics to find the best insurance agencies Bainbridge, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Insurance Agencies
Near Bainbridge, PA
KMA Insurance Group
4.8
(148 Reviews)
Featured review:
"My husband and I have been very pleased with the follow- up and service from Jared Allen at KMA Insurance with offices in Cleveland and Chattanooga, Tennessee. Jared was both professional and informative with regard to different insurance company options and provided detailed quotes for our review....
Elizabethtown
Craig Rothstein – State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9
(109 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Nice job. The only disappointment was that the details of the smart ride were glossed over and the State Farm web site was foggy on the concept. I have been driving for half a century without a claim so, if this system dings me, I'll go somewhere else." - brad b....
Elizabethtown
Josh Shoop – State Farm Insurance Agent
5
(80 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Called to add a car to my policy today and Joy Breach helped ke to add the policy, walked me through the steps to sign the documents, and answered all questions that I had today. Been a few years since I added a vehicle so wanted to make sure I was doing everything right. She was very patient and h...
Elizabethtown
Hornafius Insurance Agency
4.9
(46 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Having a new teenage driver in the house, it was time to look at our insurance policies. I had a recommendation from a friend who was happy with his company. In checking them out, Hornafius came up as an agent for this company. I was contacted by Alyssa, who was a pleasure to deal with and helped m...
Elizabethtown
Shelly Marie Santoni: Allstate Insurance
4.6
(30 Reviews)
Featured review:
"If you’re reading this, you will not be disappointed trust me!!! I meet Shelly a couple years back when I insured my first vehicle since day one Shelly has been really kind, knowledgeable, and honest. Fast forward years later here I am still with Shelly as my agent and she still to this day deliv...
Elizabethtown
Thome Insurance Agency Inc
5
(14 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Been getting my car & rental insurance
For a few years now from Thome Insurance
Never had a problem.
Shawn has always helped with any questions
I would recommend !!
Thome Insurance Agency" - william w....
Elizabethtown
Tyler Parmer – State Farm Insurance Agent
5
(10 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Tyler and Steve are the best! Tyler saved me money when I switched to State Farm,(Auto and Homeowners Insurance).They take their time and explain everything. You don't feel rushed and they are very knowledgeable. You won't be disappointed!" - Lauren M....
Mount Joy
Rutt Insurance Agency
4.9
(10 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I have experienced excellent care here with Rutt insurance. They answer the phone personally as opposed to the automated answering for big companies. It makes all the difference in the world. Jaime has been pleasant to talk to and do business with. This is an agency that treats you like a person be...
Mount Joy
Definitive Insurance Solutions
5
(9 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Joe was amazing to work with. We needed flood insurance for our new home and we were struggling to find someone who would help us. I gave Joe a call and he made it happen. He communicates clearly and in terms that are easy to understand throughout the whole process. I will definitely use him for al...
Mount Joy
Kyper Insurance Group LLC
5
(7 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I had to add my son to my insurance once he received his driver license. My insurance skyrocketed with Geico. Called Martin at Kyper Insurance Group and he saved me close to $1000 per year. He also helped us switch over our homeowners which was slightly lower than Traveller. The help he provide...
Columbia