The Lanc Local team analyzed 156,056 local reviews and metrics to find the best american restaurants Talmage, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top American Restaurants
Near Talmage, PA
Gracie’s On West Main
4.7
(2,774 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We went for the grilled cheese, and we weren't disappointed. It was probably the best grilled cheese I've ever had. Delicious bacon, chicken, and of course the cheese melted to perfection on sourdough. A fabulous combination. My girl had the pulled pork grilled cheese, which of course she loved. An...
Leola
Horse Inn
4.7
(1,229 Reviews)
Featured review:
"This place is an absolute must while in downtown Lancaster. The building itself is super cool and historic. Both bars are a great hang and all the food is superb. Their burger is one of the best I've ever had! And they have live music!"...
Lancaster
Dienner’s Country Restaurant
4.6
(4,993 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I'm so happy someone recommended that we try an Amish smorgasbord while on our family vacation through PA. I did some research and found this one with great reviews not too (40mins) far from Hershey PA, which is where we were staying and entertaining ourselves in Pennsylvania. Luckily we found this...
Ronks
Katie’s Kitchen
4.6
(3,200 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I was dining with 4 others and one friend needed to plug in her O2 and the staff accommodated us quickly with smiles. Ruthie was our server and she was absolutely delightful! The meal started with delicious homemade rolls and peanut butter spread. I ordered meatloaf and mashed potatoes and peas and...
Ronks
Tavern by Spring House Brewing Co.
4.6
(1,855 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We chose to eat here by pure chance, but boy, are we glad we did! The food was great, as was the atmosphere, but what we most enjoyed was our server, Suzanne. Suzanne was so friendly & welcoming. We will certainly be making many happy returns & telling all our friends about this place. And to the a...
Strasburg
Fireside Tavern
4.6
(1,855 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Great service, food and atmosphere. Better than eating at a huge buffet. Personalized service. Unique menu items and homemade rolls and desserts. Will definitely return."...
Strasburg
Olde Lincoln House
4.6
(1,853 Reviews)
Featured review:
"What an amazing experience. Scrumptious, homemade soups of all varieties to set one off well. Grab a grilled Reuben or turkey sandwich and you’ll enjoy real shaved meat and will not be disappointed. Finish off the meal with one of the wondrous ice cream flavors available, and then top that off wi...
Ephrata
Udder Choice
4.6
(1,851 Reviews)
Featured review:
"What an amazing experience. Scrumptious, homemade soups of all varieties to set one off well. Grab a grilled Reuben or turkey sandwich and you’ll enjoy real shaved meat and will not be disappointed. Finish off the meal with one of the wondrous ice cream flavors available, and then top that off wi...
Ephrata
PJ’s Steak & Hoagie Shack
4.7
(693 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Stopped here for lunch and I’m so glad I did. They recommended the thanksgiving sandwich which was fantastic. Cool atmosphere inside with parking in the back. Wait staff was very friendly. It seemed like a lot of good options on the menu." - Kevin W....
New Holland
Lickity Split Restaurant
4.7
(693 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Stopped here for lunch and I’m so glad I did. They recommended the thanksgiving sandwich which was fantastic. Cool atmosphere inside with parking in the back. Wait staff was very friendly. It seemed like a lot of good options on the menu."...
New Holland