The Lanc Local team analyzed 66,968 local reviews and metrics to find the best sandwich shops Paradise, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Sandwich Shops
Near Paradise, PA
Gracie’s On West Main
4.7
(2,774 Reviews)
Featured review:
"We went for the grilled cheese, and we weren't disappointed. It was probably the best grilled cheese I've ever had. Delicious bacon, chicken, and of course the cheese melted to perfection on sourdough. A fabulous combination. My girl had the pulled pork grilled cheese, which of course she loved. An...
Leola
Route 66 Restaurant – Lancaster PA
4.8
(592 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Came here looking for Lancaster’s BEST Burger, and Cabalar has definitely thrown his hat in the ring. We had a Kids Burger and a House Special. Pleasantly surprised by the fries we upgraded to - fresh cut and crispy! They butcher their meat on-site and the result is a fresh and flavorful patty th...
Lancaster
Cabalar
4.8
(592 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Came here looking for Lancaster’s BEST Burger, and Cabalar has definitely thrown his hat in the ring. We had a Kids Burger and a House Special. Pleasantly surprised by the fries we upgraded to - fresh cut and crispy! They butcher their meat on-site and the result is a fresh and flavorful patty th...
Lancaster
Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Café
4.7
(245 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Beautiful facility with tasty food at really affordable prices.
Great place to bring kids to play indoors while they snack on some yummy ice cream. Recommend the breaded pickles!"...
Gordonville
The Village Cafe
4.7
(190 Reviews)
Featured review:
"When you just love a place, it's food, atmosphere and people, you go back! The village Cafe and Latte Luv are truly local favorites, under one roof. Everything is wonderful, though...I recommend you upgrade from regular fries to their seasoned waffle fries."...
Gordonville
PJ’s Steak & Hoagie Shack
4.6
(228 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Very good cheese steaks, prompt, courteous and friendly service.
Stopped by for take out cheese steaks (medium) with curly fries. The cheese steaks were quite good and an ample portion. The rolls were right, the meat juicy, perhaps a bit more cheese would have been good - but overall very good. Th...
New Holland
Pizzeria 211
4.6
(144 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Thin crust, tasty sauce, quality pepperoni that turns into little saucers (if you know you know). Not overloaded with too much cheese. One of our favorites in Lancaster. If you know Dave Portnoy, get him here….! He won’t be disappointed. Just one bite…. everybody knows the rules…."...
Lancaster
Bird-in-Hand Bakery & Cafe
4.4
(434 Reviews)
Featured review:
"What a great little bakery tucked away in the heart of Amish country! Had the cheese Danish and the Farmers Breakfast sandwich, awesome taste and quality!!!"...
Bird in Hand
Bruno’s at Greenfield
4.5
(106 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Awesome cheesesteak! New shop is amazing and the staff is friendly and provide great service! Definitely a go to place if your in the area!"...
Lancaster
Pizza Boli’s
4.6
(68 Reviews)
Featured review:
"So I do honest reviews at every store, restaurant , etc. that I go to. My experience here has been great. Food is delicious, and customer service is phenomenal. The prices, in my opinion, are very reasonable. As you can see, the reviews speak for itself."...
Lancaster