The Lanc Local team analyzed 11,973 local reviews and metrics to find the best pizza takeout New Providence, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Pizza Takeouts
Near New Providence, PA
Nino’s New York Style Pizza
4.5
(374 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Best pizza I’ve had period. It’s home for me. The chicken tenders are great as well. Love the employees as well. The plain cheese hits like nowhere else. My favorite is the Margarita here. If you’re thinking or looking on these reviews to find good pizza.. then just go here and be happy"...
Lancaster
Pizzeria 211
4.6
(144 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Thin crust, tasty sauce, quality pepperoni that turns into little saucers (if you know you know). Not overloaded with too much cheese. One of our favorites in Lancaster. If you know Dave Portnoy, get him here….! He won’t be disappointed. Just one bite…. everybody knows the rules…."...
Lancaster
Pizza Hut Express
4
(8 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Excellent Pizza ! Staff , very friendly. Check out TA Express for great food and fuel .2622 Lincoln Highway East .Ronks Pa."...
Ronks
Domino’s Pizza
3.8
(97 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I am always very pleased with the service, quality of food, and cleanliness of the store. The staff is uber-friendly. This is my go-to quick meal, local pizza shop. I also LOVE the Pizza Tracker!"...
Lancaster
Pizza Hut
3.8
(97 Reviews)
Featured review:
"I am always very pleased with the service, quality of food, and cleanliness of the store. The staff is uber-friendly. This is my go-to quick meal, local pizza shop. I also LOVE the Pizza Tracker!" - Karen R....
Lancaster
Little Caesars Pizza
3.8
(447 Reviews)
Featured review:
"One of the better Little Caesars we've experienced. Pizza is always crispy here and ready promptly. Workers are friendly when I've had the rare chance of an encounter as I use the app which is a no contact pick up system. Actually a pretty convenient setup. Price point is basically unmatched as wel...
Lancaster
Pasquale’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
3.8
(447 Reviews)
Featured review:
"One of the better Little Caesars we've experienced. Pizza is always crispy here and ready promptly. Workers are friendly when I've had the rare chance of an encounter as I use the app which is a no contact pick up system. Actually a pretty convenient setup. Price point is basically unmatched as w...
Lancaster
Domino’s Pizza
3.8
(472 Reviews)
Featured review:
"not sure why this place has so many awful reviews. I had some pizzas delivered and they look great! super hot and the delivery guy followed my instructions to a T! Thanks guys!"...
Lancaster
Pizza Hut
3.4
(231 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Anthony the delivery driver is an absolute sweetheart! We have never had a bad experience at this Pizza Hut with delivery. Today there was a mix up where our drinks were missing from our order and Anthony went out of his way to make it up to us! 10/10 experience. Thank you Anthony"...
Willow Street
Pizza Hut
3.5
(427 Reviews)
Featured review:
"Ladies at counter super nice and grateful for business - opposite attitude of most fast food clerks (ugh don’t get food bc then I actually have to do something)
The meat lovers pizza was on sale for $12 and was one of the best pizzas my family has ever had. It looked like a pizza from an adver...
Lancaster