The Lanc Local team analyzed 53,597 local reviews and metrics to find the best italian restaurants Maytown, PA has to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Italian Restaurants
Near Maytown, PA
Little Italy Italian Restaurant
4.6
(551 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Must stop, great price, excellent portions. You can not find prices like this in the city, so if you're driving through, hit this up. The only problem is you will be too full and not comfortable. Only had pizza, but the pasta looked good also."...
Bainbridge
DiMaria’s NY Pizza and Italian Restaurant
4.6
(350 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Really good pizza for a good price. I doubt that there is a better pizza place in the area. I do not try other pizza places because I am happy to keep eating from here. I've gotten a few subs and they were good, not great. The pizza is the real star. I got the garlic knots and they weren't as go...
Mount Joy
Caruso’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza Shop
4.5
(504 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I have always loved this carusos! The food is great! I just used them for my baby shower. We did full trays of pasta and salad. You can’t beat the price for how much food we got. I was getting quoted 300-600.0 at other places for catering for only 25 people. Carusos by far had the best pricing & ...
Lancaster
Two Cousin’s Pizza & Italian
4.4
(310 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I've been eating at the Mount Joy Two Cousin's for over 30 years and have never had one complaint. The staff is very friendly and attentive. I always have a great meal here. Their Cheeseburger sub is the best I have ever had! They also have great pizza, appetizers and milkshakes."...
Mount Joy
Ferrarelli House of Wine
4.6
(58 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Homemade Pasta, enveloped in delicious sauces make every entree feel like you've been transported to Italy. You'll get a lovely serving size that tempts you to eat it all, but my recommendation is take some home. The house dressing is a lovely Italian vinaigrette with a great balance of acidity ...
Elizabethtown
Today’s Pizza & Mamma Rita Italian Restaurant
4.3
(356 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"My wife and I walk into this treasure of restaurant dinning, and take out, we just move to the Lancaster area a couple years ago, and we where having difficulty finding a Italian restaurant that serves our favorite foods, with great customer service, fair prices, and most of all! Great food!!! That...
Mount Joy
Mr Joe’s Steak House & Restaurant
4.3
(305 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I only went here because it looks so old school...like places I remember happily from my youth. I've only had two cheesesteaks from here and they were perfectly wrapped and absolutely satisfying. Seriously, my favorite cheesesteak. I just moved to Columbia and they're maybe a block from me. Thank G...
Columbia
My Place Italian Restaurant
4.3
(199 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"We have ordered here for months (takeout) and have always been happy with the deliciousness of their food. We finally dined in today and the food was excellent! If you haven’t tried them, give them a try. Their authentic Mexican food is off the hook! Their huaraches are pictured and are great! I ...
Elizabethtown
Vecchia Sicilia Pizza Shop
4.2
(279 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"Absolutely CRAZY!!! Lived ALL over the northeast for 3 years. Made a point to eat too much ;) But these guys... woah... INSANE GOOD AND LUDICROUS SIZE, both times. First was Sicilian with pepperoni, first pizza I couldn't kill in 24 hours.. Second time... cheesesteak calzone.. recommended by ...
Columbia
Parma Pizza & Grill Of Columbia
4.1
(158 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"15 out of 5. Stopped by for lunch turns out they have a buy one get one free special from 11-2. Anything on the counter. Stuffed pizza was out of this world. The pretzel wrapped dog was just as good. All I can say is come hungry."...
Columbia
This list is ranked based on reviews & ratings data. Learn more about how we rank businesses by reading our ranking methodology.
If you'd prefer to see top-rated businesses in Lancaster County by location, take a look at our map.