The Lanc Local team analyzed 5,983 local reviews and metrics to find the best thrift stores Gap, PA, and its surrounding areas have to offer. We rank businesses according to their Bayesian average rating — to prevent rankings from being overly influenced by businesses with only a few reviews.
Top Thrift Stores
Near Gap, PA
Country Gift & Thrift Shoppe
4.7
(202 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Recommended for their reasonable pricing, good selection of hidden gems, and antiques. Locals like the friendly environment of volunteers helping at the store.
Featured review:
"This is one of the most organized, friendly, and super clean thrift stores I have ever visited. Their pricing is exceptionally low considering the quality products they carry; clothing for men, women, and children, apparel accessories, jewelry, housewares, linens, scrapbooking items, yarn, magazine...
Gap
Re-Uzit Shop of New Holland
4.5
(537 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Recommended for furniture, books, and Christmas items. Locals like the ample parking and fair pricing.
Featured review:
"Lovely thrift gem. Two floors with a lot of room. Has the feel of Goodwill, but better, with a Lancaster feel. First floor is for books, clothing, and Christmas items. 2nd floor is for furniture and housewares. They have a tremendous amount of women’s clothing and a wonderful selection of antique...
New Holland
Freedom Thrift
4.8
(115 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Recommended for great prices, book selection, and household items. Locals like the unexpected finds and large selection.
Featured review:
"Wow, after driving by this after for years, I had no idea this thrift store was here. They have 2 buildings plus a tent, with an excellent selection and good prices. The main thing is their mission is to help rehabilitate people with substance abuse. It’s a great cause so I don’t feel bad buyin...
New Holland
The Bees’ Knees Family Thrift & Collectibles, LLC
5
(60 Reviews)
Locals' choice
Recommended for low prices and great selection of toys. Locals like the personable owner. A hidden gem.
Featured review:
"The owner was cordially and helpful. The store was neat and well organized, with items clearly and reasonably marked. The energy was uplifting and relaxing. My teen daughter found a lovely dress she wore out of the shop- had many compliments on it throughout the day. Well done!" - A.C....
Intercourse
Bird in Hand Re-Uzit
3.6
(11 Review)
Locals' choice
Featured review:
"I stumbled upon this store one day and was so glad I did!! This is a wonderful little thrift store! Prices are great. You never know what you might find. I never leave empty handed. I will definitely go back whenever I’m in the area." - Angie S....
Bird in Hand
This list is ranked based on reviews & ratings data. Learn more about how we rank businesses by reading our ranking methodology.
If you'd prefer to see top-rated businesses in Lancaster County by location, take a look at our map.